Image source: The Motley Fool.
Insperity Inc (NSP 0.80%)
Q2Â 2020 Earnings Call
Aug 3, 2020, 5:00 p.m. ET
Contents:
- Prepared Remarks
- Questions and Answers
- Call Participants
Prepared Remarks:
Operator
Good afternoon, my name is Jerome. I'll be your conference operator today. I would like to welcome everyone to the Insperity Second Quarter 2020 Earnings Conference Call.
[Operator Instructions]
At this time, I would like to introduce today's speakers. Joining us are Paul Sarvadi, Chairman of the Board and Chief Executive Officer, and Douglas Sharp, Senior Vice President of Finance, Chief Financial Officer and Treasurer.
At this time, I'd like to turn the call over to Mr. Douglas Sharp. Mr. Sharp, please go ahead.
Douglas S. Sharp -- Senior Vice President, Finance, Chief Financial Officer, Treasurer
Thank you. We appreciate you joining us.
Let me begin by outlining our plan for this evening's call. First, I'm going to discuss the details behind our second quarter 2020 financial results, which were strong considering the current economic environment brought upon by the pandemic. Paul will then comment on the key drivers behind our Q2 results and our outlook for the remainder of the year. I'll return to provide our financial guidance for the third quarter and an update to the full-year 2020 guidance. We will then end the call with a question and answer session.
Now, before we begin, I would like to remind you that Mr. Sarvadi, or I, may make forward-looking statements during today's call, which are subject to risks, uncertainties and assumptions. In addition, some of our discussion may include non-GAAP financial measures. For more detailed discussion of the risks and uncertainties that could cause actual results to differ materially from any forward-looking statements and reconciliations of non-GAAP financial measures, please see the company's public filings including the Form 8-K filed today, which are available on our website.
Now let's discuss our second quarter results, in which we achieved a $1.54 in adjusted EPS, an 86% increase over Q2 of 2019, and adjusted EBITDA of $92 million, an increase of 62%. Average paid worksite employees declined by just 1.8% from Q2 of 2019 compared to our forecast of 1% to 5% decline that took into account the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on our clients and prospects. All three drivers including worksite employees paid from new sales, client retention and net losses in our client base from layoffs and hiring were better than expected. Worksite employees paid from new client sales were approximately 20% above forecasted levels, driven by 15% increase in trained Business Performance Advisors and success in our mid-market segment.
Client retention held up at our historical high level of just over 99% during Q2. This points to the financial strength and actions taken by our clients during the pandemic and our quick and effective response to assist our clients with our premium level of HR services. Net losses in our client base in Q2 were lower than expected as the level of worksite employees laid off, returning to work from furlough and general hiring were all favorable. This was particularly the case in the month of June. In a few minutes, Paul will share the details on the actions we've taken recently to assist our clients and provide thoughts around more recent trends in our updated 2020 worksite employee outlook.
So let's move on to gross profit, which increased by 27% over Q2 of 2019. These results included lower-than-forecasted benefits and workers' compensation costs partially offset by our decision to provide comprehensive service fee credits to our clients. Lower benefit costs were primarily due to lower utilization, especially lower levels of elective healthcare procedures, some of which is expected to be offset in subsequent quarters with the resumption of deferred care and future COVID-19 costs. Lower workers' compensation costs were primarily a result of the effective management of claims incurred in prior periods and largely unrelated to the pandemic. Due to the structure of our workers' compensation program, any reduction in the number and severity of workers' compensation claims associated with the work from home status of many of our clients and employees would likely impact our cost in later periods as these claims develop over time.
During the quarter, we proactively engaged with our vendors in successfully negotiating savings to support our clients through this difficult period. As a result, we provided a comprehensive service fee credit to our clients based upon their worksite employee levels at June 30. These credits totaled approximately $12 million and were accrued in the second quarter. Also, under the CARES Act and Family First Act, clients were able to take advantage of payroll tax deferrals and credits offered through government stimulus packages. These deferrals and credits totaled approximately $45 million during Q2 and were reported as both a reduction to revenue and direct costs. So in total, these two items reduced Q2 reported revenues by approximately $57 million and gross profit by approximately $12 million.
Second quarter operating expenses increased by 9% and included continued investments in our growth, including costs associated with the increase in the number of Business Performance Advisors. Other corporate employee headcount has remained level over the first half of this year, even though HR demands have increased with the pandemic and its impact on the economy and a number of HR issues, including diversity and inclusion. Second quarter compensation costs included an acceleration in the timing of a portion of our corporate employees' annual incentive compensation to reward them in a period of increased service demands. Additionally, Q2 operating costs included an increased paid time off accrual associated with higher-than-normal unused vacation hours during the pandemic. These expenditures were partially offset by cost savings in other areas, including travel, training and business promotion costs.
Our effective tax rate in Q2 came in at 27%, and we expect a similar rate over both the latter half of this year and for the full-year 2020. Our strong financial position and liquidity continued to improve over the first half of 2020 in the face of the challenges and dynamics of the pandemic. Adjusted cash totaled $269 million at June 30, up from $108 million at December 31, 2019, while borrowings totaled $370 million at the end of Q2, up from $270 million at December 31, 2019. Over the first half of this year, we have repurchased 879,000 shares of stock at a cost of $61 million, paid $31 million in cash dividends and invested $39 million in capital expenditures.
Now at this time, I'd like to turn the call over to Paul.
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Thank you, Doug, and thank you all for joining us.
Today, I'll begin with a discussion of our efforts over the recent quarter to support our small and medium-sized business clients throughout the historic disruption arising from the pandemic. Secondly, I'll cover our view of the dynamics driving our expectations over the balance of the year for growth and profitability. And I'll finish my remarks with some thoughts about the long-term effect on demand for Insperity services, which represents a silver lining in the cloud of COVID-19.
This quarter was an eye opener in many ways, including highlighting the absolute necessity and the tangible value of a sophisticated HR function for small to medium-sized businesses. The unexpected events that played out over the course of the quarter cast a spotlight on the HR department, which, of course, is what Insperity is to our clients. The sequence of events beginning with the health crisis evolved into economic disruption and the transformation to working from home, followed by the emotionally charged dynamic of prolonged stay-at-home orders and political and social unrest. When you add in federal, state and local legislative and regulatory responses, with new obligations and opportunities for businesses, you have a monumental challenge and opportunity for an HR services provider to demonstrate value to clients.
Insperity Workforce Optimization has long been the most comprehensive business service offered in the marketplace and our competitive distinction is the breadth and the depth of our services and the level of care of our service providers. Our clients were relying on us to help them work through decisions that directly affected the livelihood of their businesses, employees and families. Our service teams continue to serve our clients and worksite employees with genuine care and excellence in an unprecedented time of need and constant change. In more than 30 years, I've never seen a quarter where clients experienced more of what we are designed to offer in such a compressed time period.
The effort put forth was exceptional and could have only been delivered by the combination of an amazing team and an incredible culture like we have at Insperity. The workload across the company escalated substantially with call volumes and length doubled, service interactions tripled and a long list of other services spiking. HR solutions were required for the myriad issues businesses were facing, including layoffs and staffing strategies, PPP loan application forgiveness and reporting, work from home, return to work, FICA deferral, and diversity and inclusion, just to name a few. Allow me to say we could not be prouder of our staff across the board the way they stepped up and delivered on our mission to help businesses succeed so communities prosper through a very challenging period.
Now in addition to passing this service stress test with flying colors, we also were able to see our business model perform well under the pressure of these unprecedented events. We were pleased with the dynamics across the business from sales and retention to pricing, direct cost and operating expenses. On our last call, we indicated our objective in new account sales operating in this virtual selling environment would be to fall within a range of 60% to 80% of our original 2020 pre-COVID sales budget. As you may recall, the sales budget is the internal metric we use to monitor and track performance in our sales organization. Our entire sales organization, both core and mid-market performed remarkably well, achieving total booked sales above 70% of our original 2020 pre-COVID sales budget and in the higher end of our own revised targeted range. As a reminder, once the sales booked, our service teams worked to onboard those clients and actually generate revenue as paid worksite employees.
In this environment, client retention may also be a concern due to an increase in the business failure rate in the marketplace at large. As Doug mentioned, our client retention has remained solid, reflecting the strong client base we have, and demonstrating the benefit of our strategy of targeting the best small and mid-sized businesses onto our premium services platform. Another stress test during a period like this was around pricing of our services on both new and renewing accounts. It is certainly another credit to our staff and further validation of the value of our services that our standard pricing on our book of business did not reflect unusual pricing pressure in this environment.
We were also very responsive to the immediate financial needs of our clients in providing a COVID-19 related service fee credit. During the quarter, we worked with vendors and negotiated $12 million in fee reductions to pass along to clients. We felt it was important to act quickly in this regard and get the funds to clients as soon as possible, and clients will begin seeing this credit on invoices starting this week. Another area to evaluate during this unusual time was the matching of price and cost on our primary direct cost items, including payroll taxes, workers' compensation and employee benefits. As I mentioned, pricing has remained on track. And although our quarterly direct cost pattern has changed, we anticipate a strong year overall at the gross profit line.
So we have navigated the disruption and the immediate aftermath of the pandemic and related events of Q2 successfully, and our business model demonstrated substantial resiliency. Now in order to determine our expectation for the balance of the year, we need to zero in on the most recent behavior of our clients, particularly in layoffs and new or rehires in the base and consider the economic outlook for small business. Now in the second quarter, layoffs due to COVID drove a 6% reduction in paid worksite employees from March, reaching a low point at the end of May. Now since then, we've recovered approximately 40% of this reduction, primarily due to the return to work of just over 50% of furloughed employees. At the same time, approximately 17% of furloughed or temporarily laid off employees have been reclassified to permanent layoffs, so the number of potential rehires has been reduced by two-thirds.
At this point, the rate of both layoffs and furloughed employees returning to work have moderated considerably. So determining what happens in the near term and that change in employment in our client base is somewhat of a toss-up. On one hand, it seems the small to medium-sized business community is adapting and dealing well with the new realities they're facing. We believe our client base has been particularly impressive in this regard. However, the continuing spread of the virus and the corresponding economic uncertainty may temper the rebound we have seen recently. Also, in our experience, there is sometimes a pause or hesitancy in decision-making with the uncertainty of an upcoming election, which may weigh in over the second half of the year. We do expect new account sales to ramp up over the last half of the year. However, most of the booked sales in Q4 typically do not become paid worksite employees until Q1 of the following year. These sales would contribute to growth in 2021, but not contribute significantly to this year's results.
With this backdrop, our guidance [Phonetic] for growth is somewhat conservative over the balance of the year. Although the pandemic-driven circumstances make us appropriately cautious about the near term, recent events have made us even more bullish about the long-term prospects for Insperity. Our outlook for profitability over the last half of the year also has an appropriate measure of conservatism built in. The wildcard here is in our direct costs, and particularly our health plan where some portion of lower cost experienced in Q2 is expected to shift to Q3 and Q4. This creates an unusual quarterly pattern to our profitability for 2020 shifting more of the profits to the first half than usual.
With this in mind, I believe it's very important for investors to look at the range of expectations for the full-year 2020 in context of the pandemic and focus on how we are positioned for 2021. Our full year guidance for 2020 implies a range of minus 1% to minus 3% unit growth in paid worksite employees. We expect a range of adjusted EBITDA growth that straddles to the level we achieved last year at minus 6% to plus 2%. So the big picture for the full-year 2020 is layoffs due to COVID and the economic shutdown, are expected to be partially offset by higher gross profit per worksite employee and lower operating expenses than our original budget.
So while we're continuing to focus on meeting the intense need of our client base in the current environment, we are also looking to the longer term and the straightest path to regaining our growth momentum in 2021 as COVID-19 moves further into the rearview mirror. We believe we are very well positioned for growth as we look ahead to next year. The front of our growth engine is the number of trained Business Performance Advisors, which is currently at the highest level in our history. We have deliberately continued to invest in this team throughout this economic disruption due to the likelihood of a quicker and stronger growth surge once the uncertainty diminishes. We also believe we have an opportunity to hone our marketing message, utilizing the recent positive client experiences, and we intend to increase our marketing spend in the fall to drive leads and test this new messaging.
In many ways, the unexpected and unusual developments of the last quarter validated the need for our services and the distinct advantage we provide to improve the success equation for small and medium-sized companies. Even though the pandemic has been quite a challenge, over the long term, we believe this experience will serve to increase demand within the small to medium-sized business community for Insperity services in the years ahead.
At this time, I'd like to pass the call back to Doug.
Douglas S. Sharp -- Senior Vice President, Finance, Chief Financial Officer, Treasurer
Thanks, Paul. Now let me provide our guidance for the third quarter and an update to the full-year 2020.
With the first half of the year behind us, we have more visibility as to the impact of the pandemic on our business and have seen signs of gradual improvement as businesses have started to reopen and employees have gradually returned to work. However, a high level of uncertainty associated with the pandemic, its impact on the economy and any further government stimulus packages continues to exist. The current political environment and upcoming election adds another element of uncertainty. Our guidance intends to take this into account and continues to reflect a wider range of possibilities than that provided in the past.
Based upon the details that Paul just shared on our expected worksite employee levels, we are now forecasting a 1% to 3% decrease in the average number of paid worksite employees for the full-year 2020. This is a substantial improvement over our previous guidance of a 1% to 6% decrease and reflects the more favorable starting point for the second half of the year. The low end of this guidance assumes a persistent level of pandemic cases, continued economic disruption and ultimately, a recurrence of layoffs in our client base, exceeding both new hires and furloughed employees returning to work. The high end of our paid worksite employee guidance assumes a gradual improvement in conditions associated with the pandemic and its impact on the economy, and therefore, a nominal level of growth in our client base through both furloughed employees returning to work and general hiring.
For the full-year 2020, we are raising our earnings guidance and now forecasting adjusted EBITDA of $235 million to $255 million, ranging from a decrease of 6% to an increase of 2% when compared to 2019. This compares to our previous guidance, which ranged from a decrease of 14% to flat with 2019. A component of this revised guidance is a further shift in the expected timing of healthcare utilization during the pandemic. As I mentioned a moment ago, the level of Q2 benefit cost savings largely tied to lower utilization and fewer non-essential procedures came in significantly better than our previous expectations. We expect that a portion of these non-essential procedures were deferred and some will shift into the latter half of the year, including costs associated with participants with chronic conditions that miss treatments. We also continue to expect ongoing COVID-related testing and treatment costs.
As for our operating costs, we expect continued cost savings in various areas while operating in the current pandemic environment. As we are ahead of plan on the growth in Business Performance Advisors, we intend to grow BPAs modestly over the remainder of 2020, while we intend to continue to hold our other corporate headcount flat. We are forecasting for an increase in marketing costs associated with the upcoming 2020 fall sales campaign as we promote our premier HR services in this period of increasing demand. Finally, our updated earnings guidance assumes a reduction of approximately $3 million in net interest income from our previous guidance due to the recent decline in interest rates. As for the full year 2020 adjusted EPS, we are now forecasting a range of $3.67 to $4.04, up from our previous guidance of $3.19 to $3.86.
Now as for Q3, we are forecasting average paid worksite employees in a range of 227,500 to 230,000, which is a small sequential increase over Q2. We are forecasting adjusted EBITDA in a range of $29 million to $38 million and adjusted EPS in a range of $0.37 to $0.54.
Now at this time, I'd like to open up the call for questions.
Questions and Answers:
Operator
[Operator Instructions]
Your first question comes from the line of Tobey Sommer from SunTrust. Your line is now open.
Tobey Sommer -- SunTrust Robinson Humphrey -- Analyst
Thank you. Paul, I'm interested in your perspective on the -- how this sort of recession and pandemic have played out with respect to you being able to kind of pull the playbook that you had thought you would implement in the next recession, and sort of what you've done to deal with the situation currently. It looks like the BPAs are up substantially. That's something you had hinted at, but how about the cost structure and other things like that? Thanks.
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. Thanks, Tobey. We have kept an eye on that as we've gone through this. This was more an abrupt change in reduction layoffs that you would typically find from a normal recession. But this also came with a more significant need for immediate HR support. So we have kept our corporate staff even with where we were at the time, even though there was the 6% reduction in the worksite employee base because the work of the volume has been really incredible. We've really been able to help our customers in amazing ways. But our people obviously have been really putting out a tremendous amount of extra effort.
We also think that as we see how we bounced back about 40% from that bottom already and have the organization in place to grow in the very near future, even though there's some gives and takes about this next quarter or two, we think we're positioned very well for a substantial rebound in regaining our growth momentum earlier than you normally would, if we didn't have this ongoing investment in our BPA team. And we're also going to look at really invigorating our marketing effort in the fall to kind of double down on that strategy. So we have followed our game plan, I think, pretty much. The thing that was a little bit different was such an increase in demand for the services because of the nature of the events that occurred.
Tobey Sommer -- SunTrust Robinson Humphrey -- Analyst
That makes sense. If I could pull back the aperture and look a little longer term with my follow-up. What does this do to you thinking -- your thinking about this year's fall campaign and whether you can try to slingshot the growth as early as next year? And thinking of how you and the industry provided a lot of value to sort of your customers as a category, does this change the way you think about the addressable market? Or the rate of growth over some sort of maybe five-year period for the company?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. It really does. It makes me really excited about the opportunity to use real world, tangible examples that came out of this situation in conversations and in advertising and marketing, and in telling the story to prospects in the marketplace. And I also think that businesses, in general, the ones that didn't have us -- or were not using a service like us, they felt a deep need, and it hurt. It was painful. And so I think as we become effective at telling the story and translating what occurred into the marketing message into the sales motion if you will, and the dialogue, and even getting current clients speaking with prospective clients, and whether that happens by video or referrals or whatever, I really think this is -- we'll turn in. We'll look back and say, wow, we had a nice surge of demand and hopefully, a better ability to convey the message and the value, which in our world is very important. It supports not only the rate of growth, but our pricing and our service model is all tied together in that value equation. So very excited about that as we see this immediate situation kind of get into the rearview mirror.
Tobey Sommer -- SunTrust Robinson Humphrey -- Analyst
Thank you.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Jeff Martin from Roth Capital. Your line is now open.
Jeff Martin -- Roth Capital Partners, LLC -- Analyst
Can you hear me OK?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yes, we can.
Jeff Martin -- Roth Capital Partners, LLC -- Analyst
Okay, great. I was wondering if you could kind of walk us through the cadence throughout the quarter in terms of monthly change. Obviously, April was the bottom, but you alluded to briefly May somewhat. But in terms of June and July, what have you experienced in terms of the sales efficiency, as well as headcount within the client base?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. So what I tried to lay out in my remarks there, Jeff, was that we -- from where we were in March, we had a 6% reduction in paid worksite employees by the end of May. And about 40% of that number has recovered in paid worksite employees since that time. So we're not quite halfway back from that low point to the March number, but we're well on our way, and we'll be heading that direction. Now as far as new sales, in the virtual selling environment, we took a look at our original budget. And based on what we thought we could do in the early stages of virtual selling, we decided that over the last three quarters of the year, if we could end up somewhere between 60% and 80% -- frankly, I was thinking closer to 60% in the second quarter and closer to the high end in the latter part of the year, but we ended up at over 70% of for the second quarter. And we feel confident we can continue to do that. So we're in a good place to perform really, really well, I think, in the current environment for what we're facing.
Jeff Martin -- Roth Capital Partners, LLC -- Analyst
Okay. Thank you. And then in terms of the middle market, is that an increasingly attractive area to focus given the recessionary environment we're in? And if so, what strategically are you doing to shift more to the middle market?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. We actually had -- even in the core markets, shifting to the larger customers was part of the strategy throughout the -- since the pandemic hit. But our mid-market has performed very steady through this whole period, keeping in mind that those discussions take a longer period anyway. So we had a good pipeline for that. But that pipeline has continued, and we feel really good about where we are this year. And we didn't have the same kind of negative interruption in that space just because the sales cycle is longer anyway. And you normally do have some interruptions in that process as you go through mid-market sales. So in any event, it's been more even for us through this period, and pipeline still looks good and everybody is doing the right thing. So we feel good about our mid-market segment going forward.
Jeff Martin -- Roth Capital Partners, LLC -- Analyst
Great. Thanks for your time.
Operator
Your next question comes from the line of Mark Marcon from Baird. Your line is now open.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
Good afternoon, Paul and Doug.
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Hey Mark.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
Hi. With regards to just what you're seeing from a geographic perspective, are any of the flows that you're seeing in terms of worksite employees or engagement in terms of new business tied with the various geographic surges of the virus? In other words, did you see stronger performances in June and July out of the Northeast relative to, say, Texas and California? Or any sort of correlation from that perspective?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. I think if we look at -- particularly, if you look at the layoffs and return to work as it relates to the furloughed employees by region, it would be what you would expect. The layoffs we're more concentrated in the west. I would say that's probably the highest and a little bit less than that in the Northeast. The other regions would probably be layoffs as a percentage of total layoffs, less than their proportionate share of worksite -- total worksite employees. But -- so again, what you would expect on the layoff side. But again, the same is holding true on the return to work side. And so more of the return to works are coming from those particular regions also. So I think overall, Mark, it would be what you would expect by region.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
Okay. Great. And then with regards to the healthcare cost, how much of the year-over-year improvement in terms of GP for WSEE came from healthcare costs? Or how much were the healthcare benefits down on a year-over-year basis?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
I think you could say, if you look at the gross profit, as I mentioned in my prepared remarks, sort of the outperformance in that area was due to both the benefit cost and the workers' comp. And more of the share of that did come from the healthcare cost and the workers' comp.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
And how are you thinking about that philosophically for the balance of this year and thinking about next year in terms of pricing? Do you think that the majority of what was deferred during the second quarter is going to come through in the back half of this year? Is that part of the plan? Or are you assuming that 80% or 60% of what was deferred comes back?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah. I think the best way to look at that is, if you look where we were a quarter ago, we had appropriately forecasted lower costs in the second quarter. And having that -- the bulk of that cost come through in Q3 and Q4. And what actually occurred was the lower cost was even lower than originally expected. But we still expect that same pattern where a lot of those costs come back through over the back half of the year. So that's how the model is working to this year differently than other years. But I think if you back away from the big picture, maybe the best way to look at it is, is that instead of a 3% total trend of all benefit costs that we were looking at for the full year, there -- due to the fact that there were services that were not rendered in the second quarter, people didn't go in for the things that were deferred, elective surgeries and other types of care, probably took a couple percent out of trend for the year.
But what's important for us is to be managing price and cost in the bigger picture over the longer term. And we are in very, very good shape that we've continued to manage pricing well. And as I mentioned in my dialogue, not experiencing pressure in that area. So we feel very strong that we have a very nice match in price and cost on these direct cost items. And that's why we are going to have a better year than originally expected in the gross profit area and are in good shape for the longer term.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
Great. And Paul, I really appreciate those comments. How does that make you think about next year if, let's say that instead of having the 3% increase over the course of the year, we're looking at a 1% increase, but then next year, there's probably still some more that was deferred that's still going to be in catch-up mode. How does that influence your perspective as it relates to pricing for next year?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, that's exactly what we always have to keep an eye on and be working. Remember, we really look at this on a rolling 12-month type basis internally. So we're constantly monitoring where both sides of the equation are going, the pricing, which, of course, includes the plan selection and plan design and so many factors that go into what our ultimate pricing is, client selection, employee selection, new accounts coming on, which businesses you renew. There's a lot of factors going on there to where -- that we manage to make sure our pricing is continuing to match, maybe not a short-term trend that's been impacted by the pandemic, but the longer-term picture and where things are going for the longer term. So we'll be watching that as we go month-to-month and making sure that we have price and cost matched as we go.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
And then can you talk a little bit about some of the internal dynamics that you see within your client base, specifically, you can see what their sales commissions are like, how they're performing relative to plan, how would you say that the health is today relative to -- I know that you -- obviously, the trends bottomed in March and April and May and have been coming back. But do you see -- are there any concerns with regards to, hey, there's a few companies that have been hanging on that might pull back now?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
So it's been interesting to watch. We have factored in a little bit higher client terminations coming from maybe some financial struggles and business fails. We haven't seen a lot of that, just a hair. So I think that's been, I'd say, a surprise to the upside. The other metrics that we follow that have been interesting to watch, if you look at the average pay for the same employees one year ago to this quarter, that number, which had been going up in the 3% range in a normal quarter, was down about 1%. So that you could actually see reflected in our numbers that some of our customers had to make pay rate changes and operating plan type changes that affect pay rates. So that was reflected, although it was pretty nominal when you look at the overall picture. Obviously, a smaller group of clients -- that wasn't across the board -- that was across the board number, but a smaller group of clients had deeper cuts.
Also, what was interesting was that the commissions did go down [Phonetic]. The commissions were really running at a hot level for quite a long time and came down but still came down only to a level of about 6% average increase in commissions over last year, which I thought was a particularly strong number in this environment. Not sure what to think about that other than it was good to see, and we'll be watching that closely. The other number that was interesting was overtime, as a percent of base pay, which had been running well over 10% as the economy was booming along, dropped down to about 7.5% or so. And so that does reflect capacity, the need dropping, the demand dropping and the need for overtime dropping substantially.
So we can see the effects going on, but I have to say that our small and mid-sized business customers, man, [Phonetic] they're resilient. They're innovative and they are fighters, and it's part of what makes it really fun to help them because they're going to find a way and most of the time, they do.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
That's great to hear. Can you talk a little bit more about the marketing message? Because, it's clear that you really came through for your clients during this period, and there was a lot of utilization. So how much more are we going to spend? And what sort of return do you think we're going to see? And how quickly do you think that's going to take shape?
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Yeah, we're going to spend enough to to do a good, thorough test of the messaging. We're not going crazy, spending like a ton of money until you test it. We just are going to put more money there and test some messaging. And there were some really emotional things that happened through this period, where we could see how much our clients care about their people, trying to keep them employed and keep them paid and keep -- it was just really interesting to watch. And so I would love to talk to you about the marketing message more, but my marketing guys would really be upset if I did that. And so it's kind of in that category, if I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you afterwards, so.
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
So I appreciate you're not killing me. So, thanks. Thanks, [Speech Overlap] for now.
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Thanks you.
Operator
There are no further questions at this time. I would now like to turn the call over back to Mr. Sarvadi. Please continue.
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
All right. Once again, thank you all for participating in our call and for your interest, and we look forward to seeing how things pan out over the next quarter and look forward to either having calls with people, Zoom calls, whatever the new mode of interaction is with investors over this period.
So thanks again for your participation.
Operator
[Operator Closing Remarks]
Duration: 44 minutes
Call participants:
Douglas S. Sharp -- Senior Vice President, Finance, Chief Financial Officer, Treasurer
Paul J. Sarvadi -- Management Director, Chairman, Chief Executive Officer
Tobey Sommer -- SunTrust Robinson Humphrey -- Analyst
Jeff Martin -- Roth Capital Partners, LLC -- Analyst
Mark Marcon -- Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. -- Analyst
