Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

CONSOL Coal Resources LP (CCR) Q2 2021 Earnings Call Transcript

By Motley Fool Transcribers – Aug 3, 2021 at 8:01PM

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

CCR earnings call for the period ending June 30, 2021.

Logo of jester cap with thought bubble.

Image source: The Motley Fool.

CONSOL Coal Resources LP (CCR)
Q2 2021 Earnings Call
Aug 3, 2021, 11:00 a.m. ET


  • Prepared Remarks
  • Questions and Answers
  • Call Participants

Prepared Remarks:


Good day, and welcome to the CONSOL Energy Second Quarter 2021 Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions]

I would now like to turn the conference over to Nathan Tucker, Director of Finance and Investor Relations. Please go ahead

10 stocks we like better than CONSOL Coal Resources
When our award-winning analyst team has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.* 

They just revealed what they believe are the ten best stocks for investors to buy right now... and CONSOL Coal Resources wasn't one of them! That's right -- they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.

See the 10 stocks

*Stock Advisor returns as of June 7, 2021

Nathan Tucker -- Director -- Finance and Investor Relations

Thank you, and good morning, everyone. Welcome to CONSOL Energy's second quarter 2021 earnings conference call. Any forward-looking statements or comments we make about future expectations are subject to some risks, which we have outlined in our press release and our SEC filings and are considered forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 21E of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934. We do not undertake any obligations of updating any forward-looking statements for future events or otherwise. We will also be discussing certain non-GAAP financial measures, which are defined and reconciled to comparable GAAP financial measures in our press release and furnished to the SEC on Form 8-K, which is also posted on our website. Additionally, we filed our 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2021 with the SEC this morning. You can find additional information regarding the company on our website,

On the call with me today are Jimmy Brock, our Chief Executive Officer; Mitesh Thakkar, our Chief Financial Officer; Dan Connell, our Senior Vice President of Strategy; and Bob Braithwaite, our Vice President of Marketing and Sales. In his prepared remarks, Jimmy will provide an update on the recommenced development of the Itmann Metallurgical project, a recap of our key achievements during the second quarter of 2021 and specific insights on operations and sales. Mitesh will then provide an update on our liability management initiatives, our financial performance during the quarter and 2021 guidance. In his closing comments, Jimmy will lay out our key priorities for the remainder of 2021. After their prepared remarks, there will be a Question and Answer session in which Dan and Bob will join us as well. Finally, we posted a supplemental slide deck on our website this morning, which we refer to on this call.

With that, let me turn it over to our Chief Executive Officer, Jimmy Brock.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Nate, and good morning, everyone. We capped off the first half of 2021 by delivering another strong quarterly performance in Q2. On the operations front, despite two longwall moves in the quarter, we delivered a solid cash cost performance.

Additionally, we once again demonstrated our ability to achieve strong cash flow performance by generating north of $50 million in free cash flow in Q2 of '21 and increasing the unrestricted cash on our balance sheet by more than $50 million as well. We reduced the leverage on our balance sheet and reaffirmed our ability to raise a significant amount of long-term capital through the recently completed tax-exempt financing on the PAMC -- expansion project.

On the marketing front, we continue to execute our strategic shift into the export markets. And we also strategically layered in some financial hedges in the API2 market to secure revenue visibility and capture some of the recent export market strengths for 2022. On the safety front, our Bailey Preparation plant, CONSOL Marine Terminal and Itmann project each had zero recordable incidents during the second quarter of 2021. However, our total recordable incident rate or TRIR at the PAMC finished Q2 '21 higher than what is typical for us. Although the severity level on each of these incidents was very low, we strived to perform each day at zero incidents. And our year-to-date TRIR at the PAMC remains significantly below the national average for underground bituminous coal mines.

Now, let me start with our most exciting news this quarter and provide an update on our Itmann Metallurgical Coal project. We have been very clear that one of our major strategic goals is to diversify our revenue streams and reduce the percentage of revenues associated with power generation markets. This project is a very important step in that direction. As most of you know, in early 2019, we announced the commitments of the development of our Itmann Mine project, which is a low-vol metallurgical coal mining operation in Wyoming County, West Virginia.

However, due to the unprecedented demand and earnings decline associated with the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020, we made the capital allocation decision to pullback spending on this project in order to focus our discretionary capital toward repurchasing our second-lien notes in the open market, which were trading well below par value at that time.

Now, as our debt has continued to trade up to near par levels and as our free cash flow generation has significantly improved, I am very pleased to announce our decision to recommence the Itmann project. Despite the significant pullback in project expenditures, the past 12 to 18 months were instrumental in repositioning the project. We used this time to complete initial development mine to shore up our confidence in the reserve, and we optimized plans for the Preparation Plant, to create an additional upside potential. We evaluated several options for the Preparation Plant. First, build a brand-new facility from scratch.

Second, purchase an existing plant at a nearby location and truck the coal for process, or third, identify an existing Preparation Plant for sale that could be relocated to our Itmann side. Based on our analysis, the third option made the most economic sense. And we are moving forward with relocating a higher capacity and state-of-the-art Preparation Plant to the Itmann project side which is expected to start up in 2022. By relocating the plant, we eliminate potentially long lead times on equipment and avoid inflationary pressures from steel and other construction materials. We expect to produce 900,000 plus tons of high-quality, low-vol coke and coal annually from our Itmann Number-five mine once were at full run-rate production.

We expect this to be a low-cost operation with a long reserve life of 20-plus years of production at maintenance capital levels. While the overall project capital cost has increased slightly due to the reoptimized plants for the prep plant, we believe this can be more than offset by the expanded capacity afforded by the prep plant and improved cost structure due to the inclusion of a highly efficient rail load down. The prep plant where we are relocating will have a processing capacity that is nearly double that at the plant originally envisioned for Itmann, opening up the opportunity for us to process up to 750,000 to one million product tons of third-party coal in addition to the coal from our Itmann Mine.

We expect this will create additional growth opportunity and higher revenue potential compared to the original project plan. With that, now let me provide an overview of the coal markets. We continue to execute on our multiyear transition of diversifying our sales mix and increasing our exposure to nonpower generation markets. Following a record export sales volume in Q1 of '21, we successfully placed a new record 3.2 million tons in the export market in Q2 of '21, representing nearly 55% of our total shipments in the quarter. Additionally, 47% of our tons sold were used in the industrial or metallurgical nonpower generation applications as we continue to diversify our way from traditional power generations.

As you can see on Slide five, we have continued to steadily diversify our global customer base and end-use markets since our span in 2017. And in the second quarter of 2021, our overall export volume as a percentage of total sales volume went up roughly 22 percentage points versus full year of 2017. This improvement was driven by a sharp increase in the portion of our tons going into the industrial markets, which has risen by 33 percentage points versus 2017. We continue to focus on our strategy of further reducing our exposure to a declining U.S. coal market for power generation with a heightened focus on increasing our industrial business. We believe that with our quality of coal and cost structure at the PAMC coupled with an ownership of CONSOL Marine Terminal, we are very well positioned to take advantage of developing and sustaining opportunities in the export market.

Demand for our product continued to strengthen in the second quarter of 2021 on the back of economic recovery and improved electric power and export demand. Henry Hub natural gas spot prices averaged $2.95 per million Btu during the quarter, a 73% increase compared to Q2 of '20. Additionally, average PJM West day-ahead power prices continued to improve, and in Q2 of '21, 61% above the year ago quarter. Spot pricing trends were especially encouraging given that we were in the shoulder season. Pricing has continued to improve since the end of the second quarter.

Henry Hub natural gas prices are now in the $4 per million Btu range for August deliveries with calendar year 2022 now well above $3 per million Btu. Prior to 2021, you'd have to go back to 2018 to find a month in which Henry Hub averaged $4 or more and prior to that all the way back to 2014. We remain optimistic that overall market conditions will continue to improve due to accelerating global economic recovery and a relatively muted supply response.

On the export front. We have seen sustained improvements in the seaborne thermal coal market since the end of the third quarter of 2020. Pet coke prices continued to remain supportive as a result of reduced oil production, propping up demand and pricing for Northern App coal in high CV markets. API2 spot prices also continued to rise in the second quarter of 2021, largely driven by hot and dry weather, strong LNG pricing and a limited supply response and ended the quarter improved by 82% compared to Q2 of '20. As such, we layered in commodity derivative contracts in the API2 market for calendar year 2022, which Mitesh will provide more color on shortly. Additionally, we completed four term deals in the export market during the quarter with durations from one to two years in length. And we recently contracted a cargo of PAMC Coal to China for the first time since 2018.

From a marketing perspective, it is encouraging to see that demand for our coal has continued to improve since the low point in Q2 of '20. We continue to maintain the vast majority of our core customer base and continue to see improvement in our customers' contracting appetites. Our sales teams remains opportunistic in its marketing strategy and increased our contracted position by 9.4 million tons since our last earnings release, bringing our contracted position to 24.6 million tons in 2021 and 10.9 million tons in 2022. Now, let me review our Q2 '21 operational performance in detail. Coal production at the Pennsylvania Mining Complex came in at 5.9 million tons in Q2 '21 compared to 2.4 million tons in Q2 of '20. The vast improvement despite the aforementioned multiple longwall moves in Q2 of '21 was due to a continued increase in demand for our products since the COVID-related trough and demand that bottomed out during the year ago quarter.

As a result, productivity at the PAMC measured as tons per employee hour improved by an impressive 46.7% in Q2 of '21 compared to Q2 of '20. On the cost front, our average cash cost of coal sale per ton was $28.02 in Q2 of '21 compared to $25.90 in Q2 of '20. Although this seems impaired, keep in mind that the $25.90 per ton did not reflect the $32 million in mine idling cash cost incurred during the year ago quarter. When adjusted for that, Q2 '21 cash costs significantly outperformed the prior year period. Even without accounting for that idle cost, our year-to-date average cash cost of coal sold per ton was improved by nearly 15% versus the first half of 2020. Our operations team continues to focus on maintaining tight control over cash expenditures as we move forward.

The CONSOL Marine Terminal achieved a throughput volume of 3.8 million tons during Q2 of '21 compared to 1.6 million tons in the year ago period. The significant increase was again due to improved demand in the seaborne markets compared to the trough of the COVID-19 related decline in coal demand in Q2 of '20. The terminal throughput volumes reflects a pace of over 15 million tons per annum and marks the second consecutive quarter with an annualized run-rate north of 15 million tons. Terminal revenues for the quarter came in at $17.4 million compared to $15.9 million in the year ago quarter. Despite the major increase in throughput tonnage, the impact on revenue was somewhat lessened due to the take-or-pay contract that was in place in the prior year period. Cash operating costs came in at $5.3 million versus $3.8 million in the year ago quarter.

With that, I will now turn the call over to Mitesh to provide the financial update.

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

Thank you, Jimmy, and good morning, everyone. I will start with an update on the progress we have made on our key financial priorities. I will then review our second quarter 2021 results and our full year 2021 guidance.

As we have discussed in the past, our financial priorities remain maximizing free cash flow generation, maintaining strong liquidity and reducing outstanding debt. While these remain on north star, we are now also selectively allocating capital toward strategic initiatives such as our Itmann project. After accomplishing a significant milestone of achieving a net leverage ratio below 2 times at the end of 1Q '21, we further reduced our leverage to 1.7 times at the end of 2Q '21. This was despite our recently completed tax-exempt bond offering, which we previously highlighted would increase our leverage in the near-term due to the treatment of restricted cash under our credit agreement. However, if we include the restricted cash, our leverage ratio as of June 30 would have dropped to 1.54 times. While we have more work to do on our balance sheet front, we have several initiatives underway or recently completed that we believe will create long-term value for our shareholders.

First, we continue to make strides on our overall debt reduction goal as we made total debt payments and repurchases of $18 million in 2Q '21. This included open market repurchases of outstanding second-lien notes where we spent $4.8 million to retire $5 million at a slight discount to par. We view these buybacks as a good use of capital even as the market price of our second-lien notes have rallied back to trade at near par levels.

Second, we made the discretionary decision to execute an $18.4 million early buyout option on an existing operating lease for a set of longwall shares. This decision not only saves us nearly $900,000 per month in operating lease expense for the next 12 months, but also eliminates the buyout requirement in 2Q '22 at fair market value. Given where steel prices are currently, this fair market value would most likely have been elevated and could have been close to or more than the $18 million fixed early buyout amount we executed. The early buyout also reduces the operating lease liability on our books, which rating agencies include in their leverage calculations.

Third, as highlighted last quarter, we continue to find ways to tap alternative sources of capital by successfully securing $75 million of tax-exempt solid waste disposal revenue bonds at the beginning of the second quarter. We received reimbursements from qualified expenses in the amount of $21.5 million in 2Q '21, which dates back to the initial inducement date in mid-2020. Additionally, we have $53.5 million in restricted cash associated with this financing that will be used to fund future spending on the refuse disposal areas at the PAMC and will reduce our leverage ratio over time.

From a strategic standpoint, this transaction gives us additional financial flexibility and helps to de-risk a portion of our future refinancing efforts by pushing $75 million of maturity in 2028. The transaction is also a testament to our ability to access long-term capital. It gets even more exciting when you consider that the commodity environment and our balance sheet has only strengthened since the closing of this transaction. We also expect this as a future financing avenue that could be available to us.

Fourth, to capitalize on the strength in the export market, we initiated a targeted revenue hedging strategy during the second quarter of 2021. So far, we have layered in two million metric tons of commodity derivative contracts in the API2 market for calendar year 2022 at a weighted average price of $79.34 per ton. These financial hedges ensure strong netback core prices for us for the approximately two million tons of physical contracts we signed during 2Q '21 for 2022, which are also tied to API2 prices. The good news for us is that API2 prices and other export market pricing indicators continue to strengthen. And we still have an additional 13-plus million tons of coal sales uncontracted for 2022. We anticipate a significant portion of these sales will go into the export markets.

Fifth, on the legacy liabilities front, under our current actuarial assumptions, we have a fully funded status on our defined benefit pension plan. At this point, we do not have any funding requirements for the foreseeable future and have significantly lowered our exposure to equity market volatility. As we move forward, we'll continue to focus on strengthening our balance sheet while implementing our targeted growth and diversification strategy. This includes our commitment to completing the Itmann project. We expect this project to require an additional $65 million to $70 million of capex to complete given the increased processing capacity and new train load out at the Preparation facility. This is an addition to the $24 million already spent on the project to-date since its inception in early 2019.

Recommencing this project is not an either our decision relative to our debt reduction priority. We still expect to continue to reduce our outstanding debt on our balance sheet -- and unrestricted cash. This project like all financial decisions went to our rigorous capital allocation process. Excluding any third-party revenue, we expect it to generate a rate of return north of 25% over the life of the project assuming an Australian premium low-vol coking coal price of $160 to $170 a ton, which is consistent with the actual trailing 10-year average price and the current forward strip for 2023 to 2025.

We believe the returns on the Itmann project will exceed our weighted average cost of capital, even at long-term average Australian premium low oil prices of $130 a ton. We are very excited about this project and its earnings and free cash flow potential. With that, let me now recap the second quarter results before moving on to our 2021 guidance. CEIX reported a very strong financial performance for 2Q '21 with net income of $4.2 million or $0.12 per diluted share, which included $20.4 million of unrealized mark-to-market losses related to commodity derivatives and adjusted EBITDA of $84.4 million. This compares to a loss of $18 million or $0.69 per diluted share and adjusted EBITDA of $34.2 million in the year ago quarter. In 2Q '21, we generated $94.6 million of cash flow from operations, which included $25.6 million of positive working capital changes driven by a significant reduction in our accounts and notes receivable balance.

Additionally, we spent $43.7 million in capital expenditures, which included the previously discussed $18.4 million for the discretionary operating lease buyout and we received $3.4 million in proceeds from asset sales. This resulted in free cash flow generation of $54.4 million in 2Q '21. This highlights the ability of our business to generate free cash flow in challenging markets and capture a meaningful upside in stronger markets. As a result of our free cash flow generation, we have increased our unrestricted cash position by nearly $56 million in the quarter and now have an unrestricted cash position of $146 million, which is the highest level since 2Q '19. Including the restricted cash position of $53.5 million, our cash and cash equivalents balance is over $200 million.

Now, let me provide you with our updated outlook for 2021. Due to our strong first half '21 operational performance and outlook for the remainder of the year, we are increasing our expected sales volume for 2021 to 23.5 million to 25 million tons, up from our previous guidance of 22 million to 24 million tons. Additionally, due to the efforts of our operations team to drive costs down despite inflationary pressures, so far this year, we are adjusting our expected average cash cost of coal sold per ton to a range of $27 to $28 per ton, down from our previous guidance of $27 to $29 per ton.

On the pricing front, we currently have a 2021 contracted position of 24.6 million tons at an expected average price of $44.02 per ton. The improvement compared to our prior guidance reflects the strength in the current pricing environment on the additional contracted volumes we have layered in as well as an improvement in the assumed PJM West power forwards. Finally, we are increasing our capital guidance due to the decision to recommence the Itmann project and the completed lease buyout to a range of $160 million to $180 million. As always, we will continue to reassess our guidance ranges each quarter and adjust them as necessary.

With that, let me turn it back to Jimmy to make some final comments.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Mitesh. Before we move on to the Question and Answer session, let me take this opportunity to provide a recap of our accomplishments in the second quarter and reiterate our priorities as we move forward.

First, we continue to prioritize strengthening and enhancing our balance sheet by improving our liquidity and financial flexibility. Despite shrinking access to capital for coal companies, we have had good success in identifying and tapping alternative sources of capital.

Second, despite significant inflationary pressures, we continue to keep costs at our operations under control through efficiencies, reduced discretionary spending and creativity in our supply chain management program. The team continues to look for ways to effectively drive costs down without sacrificing the effectiveness of our operations. By rightsizing our operations, we've taken some slack out of the system, allowing our four operating longwalls at the PAMC, the ability to essentially run full out. This drives efficiency and results in a sustained reduction in our average cash cost of coal sold per ton compared to our historical averages.

Third, our CONSOL Marine Terminal is one of the most strategically valuable assets in our portfolio. The terminal will be essential for executing our longer-term strategic shift into the export market, which we expect will derisk our domestic exposure and allow us to capitalize on growing international demand for our high CV product. Year-to-date, we shipped more than 50% of our total sales volume into the export market, which highlights the value of owning our own terminal and is a huge differentiator for us compared to our peers.

Finally, we're extremely excited to be in a position to restart the Itmann project. We view this project as the next phase of our strategy, which focuses on targeted growth and diversification as an additional avenue to increase value for our shareholders. This project is strategically important as it will diversify our portfolio by adding a new metallurgical coal product stream to the mix. And it aligns well with our current operations by being low cost, high margin and high quality. Before handing the call over, I want to reiterate that we are extremely proud of our accomplishments to-date and believe we have a lot of opportunity in front of us to build upon our strategic priorities.

Our capital allocation process, world-class asset and employees have helped us to come out of 2020 prime to excel in 2021 and beyond. There's always more work to do. But we continue to focus on our goal of strengthening our balance sheet and creating long-term value for our shareholders.

With that, I will hand the call back over to Nate for further instructions.

Nathan Tucker -- Director -- Finance and Investor Relations

Thank you, Jimmy. We will now move to the Questions and Answers session of our call. At this time, I'd like to ask our operator to please provide the instruction to our callers.

Questions and Answers:


[Operator Instructions] And the first question comes from Nathan Martin with The Benchmark Company. Please go ahead.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Good Morning, guys. Congratulations on the first half performance.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Thank you, Nate.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Maybe I'll start on the cost side first. You guys obviously lowered your guidance by, I guess, $0.50 a ton at the midpoint. But even if I run costs in the second half flat with your second quarter results of $28, which at the high end of your revised full year guidance, you end up right at the low end of that new guidance range. Is there something that pushes costs higher here in the second half or maybe is there a chance you could possibly outperform there?

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Nate, if you remember on our last earnings call, I said that we expect to come in at the lower half of our cost guidance. And as we look forward, there's still some uncertainties in the market out there. I mean, we have a contracted position for 2021, that's up significantly than on our last earnings call. But still, we have two longwall moves in the second half of the year, one in each quarter, whereas in that first quarter, we didn't have any. And inflationary pressures from some of the commodities that we produced with, we see those could come to us.

So as Mitesh mentioned in his comments, we'll reevaluate and look at it. But our goal is to keep a tight lease on cost where we can. And then, let the operations team do what they do best and they figure out ways to lower cost as we continue to produce. But the reason that we lowered it $1 is because of our performance to-date. And then, as we look forward with one longwall move in each quarter, we think we'll have an opportunity to still come in toward the lower end of that guidance and that's what our goal will be.

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

And Nate, I think inflation is a big part of a little bit of cautiousness here. As you know, all raw material prices have been higher since the beginning of the year. So I think that is something that we continuously monitor. I think our supply chain team has done a good job of managing that so far. But there's always some buffer related to inflation as we go through the year as things continue to be very strong in the commodity landscape.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Got it. I appreciate those thoughts guys. And then, maybe shifting over to the pricing side. Looks like you're essentially fully contracted for this year, meaning additional 400,000 tons or so at the high end of revised guidance. Should we assume those tons would likely go to the export market? And then, if we look forward to 2022, I think you layered on an additional five million tons or so there. Can you talk about the mix of those tons and give us an idea of what prices they were layered in? Thanks.

Robert Braithwaite -- Vice President Marketing and Sales

Yes. Sure. Nate, this is Bob. Just to kind of highlight 2021, as we mentioned earlier, we have now 24.6 million tons sold. The additional volume we had to get to the upper end of the guidance, I would suggest that that's likely going to go into the export market. There's still about a $5 to $10 arbitrage versus what the domestic prices are today. Even at $4 gas, I would suggest that the prices you're seeing in the publications cold desk reference and they call it the mid $50 range. We're still seeing an arbitrage in the export market. So it's likely that those volumes will go there.

As far as 2022 is concerned, we did contract an additional 5.3 million tons since our last earnings call. About 80% of those volumes were contracted into the international market. So sitting here today of the 10.9 million tons, a little over four million tons of those are contracted to go exports. And based on where we sit today, I would suggest that our export volumes will be pretty much similar to, if not a little bit higher in 2022 than what we expect to export in 2021. And again, that goes based on Jimmy's comments of our strategic shift, and then, also, again based on the price arbitrage that exists today.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

I appreciate that color Bob. And just any early thoughts on potential production levels in 2022 given the positive quarter view of the market?

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. I think as we've always said, we'll run to the market. Thus far, we've been able to run our four longwalls full out. We would want to continue that into 2022. And then, depending upon what future forecasts we see there, we could run some additional shifts or something. But I would expect our tonnage for 2022 to be very similar to what we have in 2021 with possibly some upside.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Got it. Thanks for that Jimmy. And then, just a real quick one to shift to Itmann. I appreciate all the color you guys are given on the projects and the updates there. I guess, how do we think about production ramp? I'm assuming we'll have to wait for the Prep Plant completion before we see any meaningful production, which I think you guys would say may be mid to second half '22, can you kind of talk about that? And then, maybe your decision to relocate the existing Prep Plant with additional capacity, maybe just any thoughts on the appetite you see to fill that excess capacity? Thanks.

Daniel Connell -- Senior Vice President -- Strategy

Sure, Nate. This is Dan. Regarding the first part of your question on the production ramp, we have been fortunate in being able to continue our development mining here at a reduced rate for the past number of months, and we'll continue that as we build out the plant. So that puts us in really good position when the plant becomes available, targeting kind of the Q3 2022 timeframe to very rapidly ramp-up and bring both of the additional sections on that we will need to scale-up to full production.

So I think our plan would be that during the second half of next year, we can move from kind of the controlled development mining that we've been doing to something very close to, if not achieving full production during 2022. The decision to relocate the plant is one that, as Jimmy mentioned, we ran a lot of analysis on. We had time to give that a thorough look given kind of the pause in the project during last couple of months. So we feel like we've vetted that plan very well. There are a number of reserves kind of in the vicinity of where this Prep Plant is being built that are -- have yet to be developed. And we actually have some development mining going on nearby it and then in some of the upper seams as we speak, that we'll likely be looking for a home. So we feel optimistic about the opportunity to pull third-party tons into the plant based on economics, should help to improve the product wins that we can produce coming out of Itmann.

And to be clear, the economic numbers that we've been reporting do not assume any upside from those third-party tons. So we have -- we based our decisions on just kind of an Itmann base case, and we view the third-party tons as upside to that plan.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. And Nate, just to add to that one of the things. When we were looking at the Preparation Plant, which is a big decision. As far as us ramping up to full production, the 900,000 tons plus that we had mentioned, we would not want to do that until we're processing our own coal and we can get that through. So when we looked at the Preparation Plant, one of the key factors there on our initial plan, we were going to build a much smaller plant that would be somewhere around 350 tons an hour. And then, we were going to -- if we got all the third-party business, everything, we would add that second piece on.

Well, we're buying this plant and relocating it, we have that from day one. And then, some of the increase in capital was because of the trained load-out that we're going to have. That's going to give us the ability to not only move our coal very efficiently on the rail line, but also any third-party coal that we have coming into there. So I remain very, very excited about the Itmann project. I'm happy that we put ourselves in a position to whereas we can recommence it. And I think it's going to be a nice return and be a nice project for our shareholders.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Got it. I appreciate that -- those additional thoughts, that makes sense. And then, just finally, I think Mitesh, obviously you went through some quick IRR numbers for Itmann and I might have missed some of those. But have you guys done kind of any payback period calculations for the project and what that might look like at various net price decks? Thanks.

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

Sure. I think it depends on what met price do you use. I mean some of these cases, the payback period could be as little as two to three years. I'll let Dan address some more specific payback periods if you will.

Daniel Connell -- Senior Vice President -- Strategy

Sure. No, I mean, I think as we mentioned Nate during the remarks, we've kind of run the project economics using a price strip that's consistent with both the 10-year average historic met prices and the current forward strip. And that puts you kind of in the payback range that Mitesh mentioned, I think in terms of ROI numbers, we said north of 25%. Obviously, if you run the numbers at the current market and assume that it holds out here for a couple of years, payback period becomes quite short. And these are paybacks. The ROI numbers just to clarify are based on total project capital costs since inception. If you look at the numbers on a go-forward basis, may become more attractive than what was before.

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

I think that's an important point that I want to highlight that all these economics that we ran are on total project cost basis. It's not just a go-forward capex that we used for analysis. Even though, today, if you are making that decision, you should look at go forward because that's more applicable. We wanted to make sure that the project economics hold.

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Got it. I appreciate all that information guys. Thanks again for the time today and best of luck in the second half.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. Thanks, Nathan.


[Operator Instructions] The next question comes from Lucas Pipes with B. Riley Securities. Please go ahead.

Lucas Pipes -- B. Riley Securities -- Analyst

Thanks very much, and good morning, everyone.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Good morning.

Lucas Pipes -- B. Riley Securities -- Analyst

I may have missed it earlier. But Jimmy, you mentioned the spread between the international and the domestic market. And I wondered, can you elaborate on what that spread is today, i.e. what is seeing for export tons, what is pricing for domestic tons? And then, do you have a view on what might trigger these prices to which obviously would be great to see the domestic pricing move up. So I appreciate your thoughts on there. Thank you.

Robert Braithwaite -- Vice President Marketing and Sales

Yeah, Lucas. This is Bob. Right now, I'd say the arbitrage versus kind of the published marks, the published marks are call it mid $50 levels for prompt right around $50 levels for coal strip '22. The volumes we've locked in to-date on the international side, the arbitrage is roughly around $5 or $10. And that does not include any, again, terminal revenues that we receive as well. So that's kind of the level we're at today. Going forward, I still view that this market has legs for at least another 12 to 18 months.

I mean, the supply response just is not there, not only in coal, but gas space as well. And inventories are significantly below their averages. In fact, I read an article just last week that gas reserves in Europe are the lowest they've been in over a decade. And then, when you look at pet coke, prices continue to trend upward and now 90% up year-on-year. So again, I think this market has legs on a continued -- the back of a continued post pandemic recovery and just a relatively muted supply response.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. And I would add, Lucas, going forward, when we're looking at gas prices where they are today and I can't reiterate enough the supply response just hasn't been there. So I think -- I agree with Bob. I think the market does have legs into the coming years, particularly on the international market, and that will help drive some of the domestic pricing as well. So we feel like it does have legs with demand increasing for electricity, gas prices where they are and a muted supply response.

Lucas Pipes -- B. Riley Securities -- Analyst

Thank you very much Bob and Jimmy for that perspective. In terms of your capital allocation, you're clearly shifting -- well, you're shifting toward growth with Itmann. Good to see that. And I wondered from here on out, what are your priorities? Is it more so on the capital? Is it more on the debt side, buying back maybe more --. We saw at your transaction on the capital lease side. What are some of the opportunities? And Mitesh, maybe if you could speak to any limits or restrictions you may have would very much appreciate your perspective. Thank you.

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

So let me start by saying that we are in a very strong position today and are constantly reviewing our capital allocation priorities to ensure that they are consistent with changing market conditions and provide us the best risk-adjusted return. In-line with our strategic priorities and the attractive rates of returns that we just talked about for Itmann project, we relaunched it, makes a lot of sense for incremental dollars that we are spending. Also, as I mentioned in my prepared remarks, we still have some wood to chop as far as deleveraging is concerned.

Now, debt repurchases are not as attractive as they used to be before. But given that we want to de-lever and the fact that we still have an 11% paper out there, that allows us to be opportunistic in that area. I think you'll continue to see us pay down our debt or repurchase in the open market, because as I said earlier, it's not an either or decision for us as far as deleveraging is concerned and Itmann is concerned.

The steps that we are taking with deleveraging and growing our met coal business are all geared toward one goal and that is really to create significant value for our shareholders, whether it comes from growth or from having larger equity value in the enterprise. The good news is that the market is offering us the opportunity today to launch and execute on multiple of these initiatives and returning capital to our shareholders is one of them, right? We are constantly reviewing it and hope to provide you an update in coming quarters as we execute on our near-term goals as well.

With respect to the operating leases, I don't see any big opportunities right now on that front. We saw one in the second quarter and executed on it, which I feel was one of the best projects so to speak, when you think about from a rate of return perspective. We ran the DCF some -- it was a very easy decision to make. So I think those are the opportunities we'll continue to look at and continue to deliver on some of our strategic priorities.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Yeah. And the good news is for us, it's not an either or as Mitesh mentioned earlier in his comments. With us generating free cash flow at the rate we are per quarter, we have an opportunity to do all of these things. But I want to reiterate, really excited about the Itmann project. It gives us that diversity in our product stream of having the low-vol metallurgical coal in the mix. And I think we're going to continue to do the things that we've done in the past, which enhanced the balance sheet, provides great liquidity and add a new product mix to our stream.

Lucas Pipes -- B. Riley Securities -- Analyst

Thank you very much. And when I saw those capital lease numbers, I thought I should get into the business of lending to you guys. Really appreciate all the color continued best of luck

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Thanks, Lucas.


The next question comes from Michael Dudas with Vertical Research Partners. Please go ahead.

Michael Dudas -- Vertical Research Partners -- Analyst

Good morning everyone.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

[Speech Overlap] Good morning.

Michael Dudas -- Vertical Research Partners -- Analyst

First question, maybe you can elaborate a little bit more on your domestic customer base. Again, certainly, inventories down, demand up. How urgent do you feel they are right now, especially as where we've had better economic activity going forward and where gas prices are? And any update on your customer base relative to potential coal power plant closures and your exposure there and how that may impact maybe some of your competitive suppliers as those things work through the system?

Robert Braithwaite -- Vice President Marketing and Sales

Mike, right now, we are in discussions with several domestic customers, not only for the balance of '21, but 2022 as well. Without a doubt, utilities are realizing that spot coal is not readily available as it once was. So with that being said, I do believe that there will be opportunities to lock-in some longer-term volumes to ensure they have supply going forward. So with that being said, stay tuned there. But as you mentioned, inventories are, I would say, near critical levels for many of the domestic utilities that we do serve. When I say critical levels, I'm saying sub-10 days of inventory on the ground. And with gas price at $4, I don't see that that this will change in the very near future. So again, it should bode very well for us in our contracting abilities for 2022.

As far as closures are concerned, as of right now, within the next 10 years, we have very minimal of our customer base, look -- that has announced that they will retire. I would say, it's in a neighborhood of 0.5 million to one million total tons that we view at risk. Obviously, as Jimmy talked about before is Reggie. We do have to be concerned about Reggie, which we're keeping a close eye on. That could have some additional impact on us in Pennsylvania. But again, we are continuing to look and focus on shifting some of those volumes already in the export market. So that's kind of where we stand today.

Michael Dudas -- Vertical Research Partners -- Analyst

I appreciate that. Secondly, moving internationally, say to your important market in India and you mentioned about pet coke. And could you maybe just a thought on just the dynamics going on in the Asian coal market, especially with some of the shifts in coal in and out of China and then the lack of supply response. Again, not to predict the future markets, but you got pretty strong curves out there. Relative to say -- and Jimmy mentioned your 2014 and 2018 coal price spikes in internationally. How different is it dynamic and what you're seeing here, especially as you guys have evolved into a much more important and solid provider coal into those export markets?

Robert Braithwaite -- Vice President Marketing and Sales

Yeah. One thing that benefits us as we mentioned in our remarks, our coal being a high Btu, high calorific value coal does transport very nicely into these markets, especially into the Asian markets, where there is additional transportation. As far as this time around versus what happened in call it 2014, as we mentioned, the supply response isn't there. I mean, if you look at the production, not only in the U.S. but look at the production in Colombia, I mean, it's significantly down. And they're just not -- those production basins just aren't coming back is strong. Plus not only that, there's additional build-outs internationally. I mean India obviously is a targeted market for us. They're going -- they have been going through and continue to go through industrial revolution. And then, again, with the whole Australia and China tensions continuing. It is opening up doors for us to get Bailey coal into China as well.

As Jimmy mentioned, we did contract our first cargo there this year, which is our first since 2018. So again, I think a lot of this is based on just again, a post-pandemic recovery and muted supply response that we just do not feel is coming back.

Michael Dudas -- Vertical Research Partners -- Analyst

Understood. And finally, I guess Mitesh, on your derivative book that you're creating here. Is that something that is -- I assume its opportunistic. But as we see that as you managed the pricing markets, there's a little bit more exposure to that as you move forward? Is that something that's going to be part of how you -- on the marketing and hedging side going forward, especially with your more exposure in those export markets?

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

Yeah. So Mike, you're absolutely right. I think what we did in the second quarter was more opportunistic, but it also demonstrates a tool that we have in future. I think one of the things that we have noticed is there was interest in doing API tooling contracts by some of our supplier -- by some of our customers. So we wanted to manage that risk. And in hindsight, you look at it, it almost looks like we could have waited three more months, and we would have been a lot better off.

But I think the goal there was to mitigate the risk, and I think we used it appropriately at that time. But it also gave us another tool to do some of the things where if we want to -- if we are seeing that we are not making progress on improving our contracted position, but the API2 market is there. We can lock in tons there and have some of that book.

Right now, that's not the case, but that doesn't mean it's not going to be in the future. I think our marketing team is very successful in layering in some contracts here in the export markets, even on a term basis and not just spot basis, which is really good. We like that approach much better than using the derivatives, but it's a tool that we have we can use.

Michael Dudas -- Vertical Research Partners -- Analyst

That sounds great. I appreciate your thoughts gentlemen.

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Thanks, Mike.


This concludes our question-and-answer session. I will now turn the conference back over to Nathan Tucker for any closing remarks.

Nathan Tucker -- Director -- Finance and Investor Relations

Thank you, Tom. We appreciate everyone's time this morning and thank you for your interest and support of CEIX. Hopefully, we were able to answer most of your questions today. And we look forward to our next quarterly earnings call. Thank you.


[Operator Closing Remarks]

Duration: 52 minutes

Call participants:

Nathan Tucker -- Director -- Finance and Investor Relations

Jimmy A. Brock -- President and Chief Executive Officer

Mitesh Thakkar -- Chief Financial Officer

Robert Braithwaite -- Vice President Marketing and Sales

Daniel Connell -- Senior Vice President -- Strategy

Nathan Martin -- The Benchmark Company -- Analyst

Lucas Pipes -- B. Riley Securities -- Analyst

Michael Dudas -- Vertical Research Partners -- Analyst

More CCR analysis

All earnings call transcripts

AlphaStreet Logo

This article is a transcript of this conference call produced for The Motley Fool. While we strive for our Foolish Best, there may be errors, omissions, or inaccuracies in this transcript. As with all our articles, The Motley Fool does not assume any responsibility for your use of this content, and we strongly encourage you to do your own research, including listening to the call yourself and reading the company's SEC filings. Please see our Terms and Conditions for additional details, including our Obligatory Capitalized Disclaimers of Liability.

The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Invest Smarter with The Motley Fool

Join Over 1 Million Premium Members Receiving…

  • New Stock Picks Each Month
  • Detailed Analysis of Companies
  • Model Portfolios
  • Live Streaming During Market Hours
  • And Much More
Get Started Now

Stocks Mentioned

CONSOL Coal Resources Stock Quote
CONSOL Coal Resources

*Average returns of all recommendations since inception. Cost basis and return based on previous market day close.

Related Articles

Motley Fool Returns

Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Market-beating stocks from our award-winning analyst team.

Stock Advisor Returns
S&P 500 Returns

Calculated by average return of all stock recommendations since inception of the Stock Advisor service in February of 2002. Returns as of 11/28/2022.

Discounted offers are only available to new members. Stock Advisor list price is $199 per year.

Premium Investing Services

Invest better with The Motley Fool. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from The Motley Fool's premium services.