The decline sent the stock to a new low, down 24% since shares began trading in late 2016.
The cosmetics specialist's fiscal second-quarter results, released early in the month, left many investors wanting more. In that announcement, the company showed strong sales growth and a healthy expansion in profitability. Revenue gains sped up to a 27% pace from 15%, and gross profit margin jumped to 64% of sales from 57% a year ago. Highlighting those top- and bottom-line improvements, CEO Tarang Amin said the executive team was "pleased with our strong progress."
Detracting from that good news was the fact that expenses ate up a bigger proportion of earnings as the retailer continues to adjust to life as a public company.
Amin and his executive team still see revenue growing by between 24% and 28% this year to as much as $295 million. Continued investments into building out the brand and the improving the selling infrastructure will keep a lid on earnings growth, though, and so net income should only expand slightly from last year's $18 million.
That profit speed bump shouldn't threaten e.l.f.'s positive long-term trajectory, which today is being characterized by market share gains and healthy pricing in an altogether weak industry.
More from The Motley Fool
Why e.l.f. Beauty Stock Tumbled 11% Today
Management just doubled down on guidance -- but it wasn't enough.
What Happened in the Stock Market Today
On a record day for the indexes, Illumina stock rose on a product announcement and positive outlook, and e.l.f. Beauty fell following a lowered growth forecast.
e.l.f. Beauty Cuts Its Outlook on Industry Weakness
The cosmetics retailer forecast a sharp growth slowdown over the key holiday shopping season.