What happened

Shares of professional wrestling promoter World Wrestling Entertainment (NYSE:WWE) popped more than 10% after reporting an earnings beat Thursday morning, ultimately closing the day up 8.7%. 

Expected to earn just $0.04 per share on $275 million in sales for its fiscal second-quarter 2019, WWE instead reported a $0.10 per-share profit despite sales falling short of estimates at $268.9 million. 

Cartoon wrestler hoists title belt in the ring over a fallen opponent

Image source: Getty Images.

So what

This was a sort of bad news/good news quarter for World Wrestling Entertainment. Sales declined 5% year over year, about twice as bad as analyst estimates had predicted. Profits, on the other hand, were expected to decline from the $0.11 per share WWE earned a year ago, but instead, they held steady.

Management attributed the better-than-expected results to "steady improvement in engagement metrics ... reduced losses on equity investments and a lower effective tax rate."

Now what

Going forward, however, the news might not be as good.

Company co-President George Barrios warned that while "earnings exceeded guidance" in Q2, "we anticipate a portion of this to reverse" in coming months. "Adjusted operating income before depreciation and amortization [OIBDA]" is expected to decline year over year in Q3, "primarily due to increases in fixed costs, including the impact of investment, as well as lower WWE Network subscription revenue, which more than offset the escalation of core content rights fees."

Nonetheless, management insisted it will still hit its targeted "Adjusted OIBDA of at least $200 million" for the full year. Viewed in conjunction with the Q2 beat, this continued confidence in full-year results probably explains investors' decisions to applaud the results despite weak Q3 guidance and the revenue miss in Q2.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium advisory service. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis -- even one of our own -- helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer.