Sirius XM (SIRI 0.28%) is one of those controversial stocks. On one hand, it's a cash flow machine with a loyal user base. On the other hand, its growth engine has stalled, and investor sentiment for the stock has waned.
So, is Sirius XM a hidden gem or a classic value trap? Let's examine one red flag and one green flag that every investor should consider before purchasing the stock.
Image source: Getty Images.
Red flag: Growth has turned negative, and this may be a structural issue
Sirius XM's most significant challenge today is that it is no longer growing. From 2022 to 2024, revenue decreased slightly from $9.0 billion to $8.7 billion, primarily due to a decline in subscriber revenue. That's a concerning trend for any business built on a subscription model. Similarly, adjusted earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization (EBITDA) has contracted from $2.8 billion to $2.7 billion during that period.
At a high level, Sirius XM is a mature platform in a saturated market. Most new vehicles already come with Sirius pre-installed, meaning the easy growth from first-time activations is no longer available. And while it still holds a commanding share of the in-car radio experience, the broader audio landscape is shifting underneath it.
Younger listeners are flocking to Spotify, YouTube Music, and podcasts -- platforms that offer algorithmic curation, on-demand content, and social integration. Despite efforts to diversify through Pandora and its podcast network, the media company has struggled to keep up. Pandora's revenue, for instance, has remained stagnant at around $2.1 billion for two years.
To counter the revenue decline, management has leaned on cost-cutting, capturing $350 million in gross savings in 2023 and 2024. In 2025, it aims to reduce another $200 million in expenditures. While this helps maintain its cash flow, it's ultimately a defensive move. You can cut costs to protect profits in the short term, but you can't cost-cut your way into long-term growth.
The big question is whether this slower growth is cyclical or structural, driven by the deeper behavioral shifts in how consumers engage with audio. If it's the latter, Sirius XM may face years of stagnation or negative growth, unless it can reinvent itself meaningfully.
Green flag: Sirius XM is still a cash flow machine
While growth may be slowing, Sirius XM's cash flow generation capability remains surprisingly strong. In 2024, the company generated $1.0 billion in free cash flow on $8.7 billion in revenue, representing a healthy margin of approximately 11%. While revenue is declining, the audio company's cost-cutting activities may result in higher free cash flow in the coming quarters.
This cash flow strength gives Sirius something many growth-chasing firms don't: financial flexibility. One thing to note is that Sirius has been paying out dividends, so investors can expect this trend to continue. However, the most significant opportunity lies in using the leftover cash to buy back its stocks, especially since it has no clear use for that capital in growth expansion.
To this end, Sirius has been a consistent buyer of its stock, spending approximately $0.9 billion on share repurchases between 2022 and 2024. Moreover, with its stock trading close to its five-year low valuation, at a price-to-free-cash-flow (P/FCF) ratio of 8.1 times (as of writing), buying back the stock today would add enormous value to shareholders.
In an environment where many tech-adjacent media companies are burning cash or diluting shareholders, Sirius stands out as a disciplined, cash-rich operator. That profile might not excite growth investors, but for value-focused investors, it's a key reason to keep this stock on watch.
What does it mean to investors?
Sirius XM isn't going to be the next Spotify or Netflix -- and it doesn't need to be. For investors who value dependable cash flow and disciplined capital return, this stock offers real appeal, especially after its recent pullback.
Still, it's hard to ignore the structural headwinds. If listener behavior continues to shift away from satellite radio, Sirius could face a long period of stagnation.
Having the right expectations is key when holding Xirius XM's stock.
