Millions of investors want one thing from their stock portfolios: steady, reliable dividend income. Yet even among the best-known stocks in the U.S. market, you can't rely on every company to give you the consistent quarterly payments on which many depend to make ends meet.
Unfortunately, many dividend investors never realize how important dividend stability is until it's too late. If you only look at how much a stock happens to be paying in dividends right now, you could be in for a big surprise if something happens down the road to jeopardize that payout.
As many people learned the hard way during the financial crisis three years ago, even huge companies with decades-long histories of maintaining their dividend payouts through thick and thin, such as Dow Chemical
That's why I thought it would be good to take a look at five stocks from the Dow Jones Industrials
5-Year Average Annual Dividend Growth
Bank of America
Source: S&P Capital IQ. As of Dec. 22. NM = not meaningful because of negative earnings.
In contrast to our list of the fastest Dow dividend growers that we looked at yesterday, these stocks aren't particularly surprising. Three of them are hard-hit financial stocks that ended up needing bailouts through the federal government's TARP program. The others faced a combination of general economic troubles and company-specific liquidity needs.
But not all of these stocks are in the same straits right now. Some have started restoring their dividend cuts, while others remain in the doldrums. So the big question going forward is this: Will these cuts prove to be permanent, or is relief on the way for long-term shareholders?
Bring back the money!
To answer that question, let's take a closer look at these Dow stocks:
- B of A had the worst return among major banks in 2011. It resorted to getting a $5 billion infusion from Warren Buffett and has sold off significant assets in an attempt to build up capital reserves. Yet the biggest slap in the face came when the Federal Reserve refused to allow the bank to raise its dividend, keeping it locked at its penny-per-share TARP level. That could last a long time until B of A can demonstrate a more solid financial condition.
- Alcoa also hasn't made a move to boost its dividend after the more than 80% reduction in 2009 from $0.17 per share down to $0.03. Earnings continue to disappoint, and management isn't confident that things will pick up anytime soon.
- GE, on the other hand, has started to push its dividend back up. In fact, the company has raised its payout three times in the past year and a half. It's still less than half its pre-cut level, though, so GE has a lot more work to do to get things back to normal.
- JPMorgan Chase is also on the road to recovery. Unlike B of A, JPMorgan was permitted to restore a lot of its payout's lost ground, quintupling the dividend earlier this year to $0.25 per share quarterly. That's still below the pre-crisis $0.38, but with a relatively healthy position compared with its peers, the bank has a reasonable yield again.
- Pfizer cut its dividend in half to help finance its acquisition of Wyeth. The drugmaker has made two small boosts since, but the payout still stands 37% below its pre-cut peak. With major drugs coming off patent, the big question is whether Pfizer needs to hang on to its capital either to make more acquisitions or to spend more on research and development.
Don't settle for less
Unfortunately, these five stocks betrayed the trust of their shareholders in cutting their dividends. When you need dividend income to make ends meet, you can't afford to deal with stocks that won't meet you halfway. Some of these stocks may eventually match their old dividends, but investors will never look at them the same way again.
We think there are stocks that offer you more attractive dividend prospects. Read The Motley Fool's latest special free report on dividends and learn about 11 stocks that should give you what you want. But don't wait -- get your free copy while you can.
Fool contributor Dan Caplinger hates dividend cuts. You can follow him on Twitter. He doesn't own shares of the companies mentioned in this article. The Motley Fool owns shares of JPMorgan Chase and Bank of America. Motley Fool newsletter services have recommended buying shares of Pfizer. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Fool's disclosure policy won't cut you off.