It may be expensive, and it may still use that homely, old-fashioned Mac font, but the iPod is selling like, well, like the iPod. In its second quarter, Apple
Overall, sales growth was 29%, and the revenue boost trickled down to the bottom line, yielding earnings per share of $0.14 -- before a charge -- tripling last year's results, and topping analysts' expectations for a dime per stub.
And there was much rejoicing. The stock shot up over 7% to a 52-week high. Analysts are gushing. The Mac faithful are cheering. So why am I just sitting here with a curious look on my face? It's because Apple's got a few questions to answer before it looks smart for investors to rush into this party.
First, a nit to pick. Hey, Apple, what's the effect of foreign exchange? When 43% of your revenue comes from overseas, and the dollar has seen an ugly haircut over the past year, you need to explain how much of your 29% year-over-year revenue growth is owed to the currency fluctuation.
Next, what about computers? Central processing unit (CPU) sales were up a slim 6%, which lags the worldwide computer market's recent gains. During today's conference call, management didn't have a good answer to that criticism, other than to say that they "hear" that people who are buying iPods are also buying Macs. Sure, guys. Mind if we see some numbers on that?
And finally, how good is this music business? The much talked-about iTunes service may make headlines, but it's barely profitable. And margins on the iPod are expected to drop drastically once the mini can keep up with demand. Until now, competition in both segments, from the likes of Wal-Mart
Apple has earned the right to enjoy the iPod's success, but investors need to be very careful that they aren't saddling up a one-trick pony.
Dell is one of David Gardner's Motley Fool Stock Advisor recommendations. You can sign up for six months with a money-back guarantee.