It seemed like a surefire hit: Unite Nintendo's (OTC BB: NTDOY.PK) top-selling Wii console with the popular music-simulation game genre to create Wii Music. Surely, the world would lift high its lighters and cheer for an encore.
So why the deafening silence?
Wii Music has been a disappointment, according to this morning's Wall Street Journal. The newspaper leans on industry watcher NPD for data, showing that Wii Music sold just 297,000 copies last month. That doesn't compare well to Activision Blizzard's
The article also points out that older Nintendo titles, like Wii Fit and Wii Play, are outselling the music-improvisation game.
Am I worried? Not particularly. Activision's Guitar Hero franchise has a few years of brand recognition under its belt, so of course it'll have the initial advantage. Wii Fit has benefitted from initial shortages when it first came out, so the breakthrough exercise title is still coasting on months of built-up demand. And Wii Play? Come on, now. The only reason that title sells briskly is because it comes with an extra Wii controller for the price of a stand-alone game.
None of which guarantees that Wii Music won't be a flop, of course. Game designer Shigeru Miyamoto created Mario, Link, and in recent years, Nintendogs for the DS and Wii Fit. Nintendo's willingness to take chances on Miyamoto's wild ideas has helped the company smoke Sony
If anything, Nintendo may ultimately miss here because it showed up fashionably late for a change, long after Guitar Hero and Viacom's
However, Nintendo doesn't need Wii Music to be a hit this season. The 11 best-selling items in Amazon.com's
And yes, Wii Music is one of those best-sellers. Maybe this musical bet will prove a sleeper hit on its way to the top of the charts.
Stay in tune with further Foolishness: