The headlines immediately following the release of MGM Mirage's
During the quarter, MGM closed on the sale of its TI property -- the sexed-up transformation of the Treasure Island -- which resulted in a $190 million gain. The company also benefitted from $22 million from various insurance payouts stemming from the fire at the Monte Carlo back in early 2008.
Back the above items out of earnings -- and we'll even give MGM credit for the one-time preopening and start-up costs that it spent -- and that nice-looking $0.38 per share falls to a $0.10 loss. For those keeping score with Wall Street, that was $0.03 below what analysts had been expecting.
The results were affected by what you might expect -- conventions were canceled, people were jamming fewer coins into the slots, and rooms were tougher to book. The only holdout for the company appeared to be the high-end gambler; MGM reported that its baccarat volume was down just 1%.
While this helped MGM, it could be even better news for Wynn
Now bulls will most likely either take issue with my characterization of MGM's results or suggest that they're a relatively meaningless look backward. After all, the media is talking about green shoots, mustard seeds, and a whole mess of other gardening metaphors.
A general air of bullishness has been boosting the entire casino industry from MGM and Wynn to Melco Crown Entertainment
But let's not get ahead of ourselves here. Once we back out the one-time events from MGM's results, EBITDA fell 38% from last year to about $350 million, which gives the company a meager two-times interest coverage. The company may have a pass from its lenders for the next few months, but unless those green shoots turn into full-blown flowers for MGM soon, it could face some tough decisions.
Bear in mind that even if bankruptcy isn't the fate of the company, harsher lending terms, asset sales under duress, and the like can all be bad news for equity investors.
So while I most certainly tip my hat to MGM and its management team for staying afloat -- not to mention keeping up the CityCenter construction -- I maintain that it's best to be very picky about where you fish in the gaming industry, and know when you are investing and when you are gambling.
Fool contributor Matt Koppenheffer does not own shares of any of the companies mentioned. You can check out what Matt is keeping an eye on by visiting his CAPS portfolio, or you can follow Matt on Twitter @KoppTheFool. The Fool's disclosure policy has never once been caught with its pants down. Of course, it doesn't actually wear pants.