Shares of Blockbuster
CEO Jim Keyes attempted to calm frayed nerves after the stock's slide. Blockbuster's Friday afternoon press release was peppered with upbeat quotes. The chain has "adequate liquidity" to get through the year. There are "promising negotiations" with its partners. However, even Keyes concedes that there are "execution risks" in seeing the retailer's objectives through.
How could things have gotten this bad?
DVDs aren't dead yet
In theory, Blockbuster should be doing okay. Movie theaters set box office records last year. This should be good for the chain in two regards.
- Hot movies hitting the big screen last year should be popular rentals when they reach the retail market several months later.
- Scintillating results for exhibitors validate the theory that cinematic escapism is a winner during an economic downturn. If folks are going out to watch a movie, they should also be willing to head to the local video store to rent one.
But reality bites. Revenue slipped 13.8% during the first quarter, and a year-ago profit turned into a significant loss this time around.
The top line deserves an asterisk. Blockbuster has been closing stores, exaggerating the loss. Comps actually fell by a more modest -- though still problematic -- 7.1% globally and 7.8% domestically.
There's no need to organize a lineup of likely suspects. We know that Blockbuster's loss is a gain for Netflix
After all, consumer appetite for movies isn't waning. Even as Blockbuster declines, Netflix has seen its subscribership grow 35%, to 14 million this year. Coinstar is growing even more quickly. Its DVD revenue has climbed 70% over the past year, with Redbox now accounting for 75% of the company's revenue.
In other words, Blockbuster can't blame the industry. The combined $208 million in revenue growth that Coinstar's DVD business and Netflix have drummed up over the past year far exceeds Blockbuster's $146 million top-line shortfall.
Movie studios have been bellyaching over waning DVD sales for a couple of years, but rentals are alive and well in the digital age -- at least for now.
The clock is ticking
Antsy creditors and worrywart auditors are making things tense at Blockbuster. That's a pity, because the company recent caught several unusual breaks:
- Its nearest old school rival -- Movie Gallery -- announced earlier this month that it would liquidate its stores.
- Blockbuster is taking the Redbox challenge head-on. NCR
(NYSE: NCR)has teamed up with the chain to deploy more than 4,000 Blockbuster Express kiosks. That number exceeds the 3,240 stateside Blockbuster stores remaining at the end of the quarter.
- Netflix and Redbox have struck deals with several major studios to delay new releases by 28 days. But Blockbuster has been able to maintain its ability to rent new releases the day they hit the market. Blockbuster's been flaunting that great edge (especially over Redbox) in its marketing.
A cockier Blockbuster with a cleaner balance sheet would be eating this up. Instead, as a consumer-facing company, all of the bankruptcy chatter may be eating away at its potential renter base. The typical Hurt Locker renter doesn't know the difference between bankruptcy reorganization and liquidation.
This isn't Blockbuster's only problem. Advertising and G&A costs are rising (as a percent of sales) as the chain shrinks. Interest expense nearly doubled over the past year. Merchandise sales -- at the domestic store level -- are also fading faster than rental revenue. This is a bit of a shock, given CEO Keyes' retailing pedigree.
I still like Blockbuster's long-term chances, but I'm certainly concerned about the fate of common shareholders, given the real possibility of a bankruptcy reorganization that will likely wipe them out.
Some closing optimistic thoughts
With a more benevolent balance sheet, it'd be easy to warm up to Blockbuster.
If folks are willing to pay a premium for 3-D and IMAX
Technology doesn't have to be Blockbuster's enemy, especially if richer platforms give optical discs some advantages over streaming video. Broadband providers are starting to get nervous about the data abuse of their "unlimited" connectivity plans. If they crack down on bandwidth use, they could destroy the digital streaming revolution in its infancy.
Blockbuster hasn't been asleep at the tech wheel. It teamed up with Deutsche Telekom's
Blockbuster sorely needs to hop on the Netflix streaming smorgasbord bandwagon -- instead of simply selling individual digital rentals -- and it certainly has the working relationships with Hollywood to do just that.
Given its dire financial straits, it would be a huge gamble to buy into Blockbuster these days. However, over the long haul, the market's not giving Blockbuster due credit for its potential as an entertainment retailer.
Will Blockbuster file for bankruptcy this year? Share your thoughts in the comment box below.
Best Buy is a Motley Fool Inside Value recommendation. IMAX is a Rule Breakers selection. Best Buy and Netflix are Stock Advisor picks. Motley Fool Options has recommended a bull call spread position on Best Buy. The Fool owns shares of Best Buy. Try any of our Foolish newsletters today, free for 30 days.
Longtime Fool contributor Rick Munarriz can't remember the last time he went into a video store for a rental. He does not own shares in any of the stocks mentioned in this story, except for Netflix. Rick is also part of the Rule Breakers newsletter research team, seeking out tomorrow's ultimate growth stocks a day early. The Fool has a disclosure policy.