When investor Jeremy Grantham speaks, I listen. He's not afraid to let a contrarian mind-set lead him in a different direction from the crowd. Recently, Grantham believed some high-quality companies traded at attractive prices. Grantham wasn't sure why the high-quality names were on sale, but he thought they offered the best returns for the next seven years. He has a pretty good long-term track record of sniffing out where the best returns are, so let's see what companies Grantham is rooting out.

What do "high-quality" and "on sale" mean? Certainly, they will represent different things to different people. For our purposes, let's say high-quality companies have a strong balance sheet and generate excellent returns on invested capital. We'll use free-cash-flow yield (free cash flow / market cap) compared to the 10-year Treasury yield as a proxy for value.

So a Grantham-like opportunity would have:

1. Net cash position > 0
More cash than debt can indicate a strong balance sheet.

2. ROIC > 15%
Earning a 15% return should be more than a company's cost of capital.

3. FCF / P > 4%
10-year treasuries are yielding about 3%. We want more return than that.

With the definitions out of the way, let's see if Hibbett Sports (Nasdaq: HIBB) can pass our sniff test.

As you can see from the table below, Hibbett Sports has a positive net cash position on its balance sheet. What's more, the company currently earns a return on invested capital that is higher than its cost of capital. Fools love companies that take shareholder capital and create value with it.

Company

Net Cash

ROIC

FCF/P

Hibbett Sports

$71.2

21.3%

4.4%

Dick's Sporting Goods (NYSE: DKS)

$65.0

11.3%

7%

Big 5 Sporting Goods (Nasdaq: BGFV)

-$62.0

11.1%

6.5%

How does it stack up to the competition? Dick's Sporting Goods has a net cash position and an attractive free-cash-flow yield, but for this test, its ROIC doesn't quite put the ball in the basket. Big 5 Sporting Goods looks cheap, but it doesn't meet the other two criteria.

Foolish conclusion
Would Jeremy Grantham buy Hibbett Sports? That's really hard to say. After all, he's his own investor. But with quality numbers like the ones above, I have to believe Grantham would certainly give Hibbett Sports a good, hard look. And you and I should, too.

The Motley Fool is recommending 50 stocks in 50 days for its new "11 O'Clock Stock" series. For more information, click here. Then come back to Fool.com every single weekday at 11 a.m. ET for a brand-new pick!

Million Dollar Portfolio Associate Advisor David Meier does not own shares of any of the companies mentioned. The Motley Fool has a healthy disclosure policy.