Level 3 Communications
But content delivery competitor Akamai Technologies
The word on the Street
Wall Street analysts sure took Akamai's soft guidance as a bad sign for Level 3. Over the last 30 days, the consensus earnings estimate has fallen from a $0.51 net loss per share to a deeper $0.60 hit. However, even the redder pen paints a brighter picture than the year-ago quarter's $1.80 loss per share.
Sales are expected to jump 71% year over year to $1.6 billion. Before you break out the bubbly to celebrate, remember that Level 3 bought networking rival Global Crossing last year, making a direct comparison pretty useless. For what it's worth, Level 3's stand-alone sales grew 3% year over year in the last quarter while Global Crossing's revenue shrank 4%. The combined sales fell 1%.
Fellow Fool Tim Beyers is troubled by Level 3's weak grip on cash flows, and I can see why:
You can interpret negative earnings as a successful tax-evasion ploy, but burning cash still smells like a forest fire. Now, management did promise on the last earnings call that "our ability to generate free cash flow should improve markedly over the next four to six quarters." Then again, the same people said last summer that the last three quarters of 2011 should break even in terms of free cash, and the chart above shows how that promise worked out.
Will Level 3 follow Akamai?
All that negative stuff aside, you should know that Akamai is a poor proxy for Level 3. Content delivery is Akamai's bread and butter, but only 1.6% of Level 3's core networking sales last quarter. The segment is growing like wildfire, but even with doubled sales year by year it'll take a while to move the needle.
The big telecoms don't work well either, being tethered to the rapidly changing wireless communications market. But regional telecoms CenturyLink
Level 3 doesn't look good in that company. Both CenturyLink and Frontier are profitable while Level 3 is not. To rub salt in the wounds, Level 3 doesn't -- read: can't afford to --pay a dividend while CenturyLink serves up a tasty 7.5% yield and Frontier's payout ratio hits double digits at 10%.
I recently showed you how Level 3 divides investors into one camp of turnaround-sniffing fans and another full of pessimists who can't stand negative cash flows. That's also where I started my bearish CAPScall on the stock, because I don't see the company delivering on its promises. Management gets their turn to prove me wrong on Wednesday, but I remain a skeptic. The real turnaround experts are investing in a totally different sector these days.
We Fools may not all hold the same opinion, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days.