We all wish we had just one more shot at the stock we forgot to buy. For some, it's Google or Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL). For others, like Warren Buffett, it was Wal-Mart in the 1980s. The problem is, some investors believe they can time-travel and buy a hot stock anyway, at any price. That's the exact formula for losing money in the markets.
For Netflix (NASDAQ:NFLX), many have already experienced this pain. The stock skyrocketed to just under $300 in mid-2011, when nobody was worried about content costs or Qwikster. Those who placed their long bets anytime around there lost their shirts, as the stock went to almost $50 shortly after its peak. Now, Netflix is back in a big way, having recovered to near-record highs. Are you going to make the same mistake twice?
Netflix is a great company with a strong management team. It's the leader in streaming services, and it will continue to dominate the space for the foreseeable future. At $60 per share, the company was a steal. At $100 per share, it was a bargain. At today's $242 per share, it's approaching fairy-tale valuations.
At its current price, Netflix is trading at nearly 80 times expected one-year earnings. For every dollar Netflix is set to earn in 2013, you, the investor, are paying them $77 in the expectation that the company will grow phenomenally (as it has) for quite some time. This just isn't a good idea.
"But House of Cards was so good!"
I know, I know. Kevin Spacey is the best fake-congressman in our nation's history. And with Arrested Development coming out in just a week, how could the company not win? It will win. I'm expecting subscribers to continue growing at a high rate as the company turns to in-house content production to battle the rising costs of media, while providing a superior product to users.
As a company, you can't say enough good things about Netflix's recovery from Qwikster-gate. As outlined in a recent article, Reed Hastings executed the perfect apology for a CEO-blunder -- he admitted fault, corrected back to pre-blunder, and then went on to build an even better product.
Look elsewhere, please
Netflix has made its big gain, again, and if you missed the opportunity, I'm sorry. But now is not the time to right your wrong -- this ship has sailed once more. Wait for valuations to come back to Earth, or for the company to start producing Tyler Perry movies in-house. Then, you may get one more chance at stealing Netflix.
As for now, high-profile, tech-hungry investors may want to divert their attention to another star fallen from grace: Apple. The traditional iPhone is nearing the end of its shocking life cycle, as competitors have finally come up with strong alternatives. A fully reworked device can't be far off. In the meantime, the stock has gotten pummeled and is offering investors a piece of one of the world's most innovative companies at less than 10 times earnings. And with $120 billion in cash taken out of the equation, EBITDA is trading at just 6.7 times firm value.
Whether you have faith in the longevity of Apple or not, just please reconsider buying Netflix at these levels.
Fool contributor Michael Lewis has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends and owns shares of Apple, Google, and Netflix. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.