Having conquered the southern mid-Atlantic region and the Carolinas with its acquisition of Harris Teeter (UNKNOWN:UNKNOWN), will supermarket powerhouse Kroger (NYSE:KR) add the Northeast to its dominion, one of the few areas of the country where it doesn't have a presence?
While the grocer itself recently said it would be at least six months before it could consider making more acquisitions, a Wall Street Journal article last week suggested Kroger is on the short-list of candidates to buy up Great Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co., which recently emerged from bankruptcy and also operates the Pathmark, Food Emporium, Waldbaum's, and A&P chains. While it has a presence in Delaware and Maryland, states that Kroger is already well acquainted with, A&P, as the corporate giant is more commonly known, is heavily represented in Connecticut, New York, New Jersey, and Pennsylvania, areas that Kroger -- and Harris Teeter, for that matter -- have yet to penetrate.
It's certainly a rich market to tap. Even the ailing A&P chains had racked up almost $9 billion in sales before entering bankruptcy protection in 2010. But intense competition from mass retailers like Wal-Mart and Target, as well as the deep discounters like Dollar General and Dollar Tree that added food and other consumables to their aisles, cut into performance.
The Northeast is also a high-cost region to operate in, particularly because of labor costs, and it was only because of concessions approved by the heavily unionized chain that A&P was able to be bought by private equity in bankruptcy rather than sold off piecemeal. Add in a series of ill-timed acquisitions such as the 2007 buyout of the Pathmark chain, which itself has been a perennial underachiever, and the addition of a boatload of debt, and A&P has not been a top-notch profit center.
The Journal puts a potential value on A&P at around $1 billion, and also names Stop & Shop parent Ahold as a potential acquirer, as well as P/E firm Cerberus Capital Management, but there are doubts any of the three would actually want A&P at the moment.
As mentioned, Kroger is still swallowing Harris Teeter and has said it needs time to make more acquisitions. Royal Ahold (NASDAQOTH:AHONY) is also said to be leery about doing large acquisitions these days, while Cerberus recently finished acquiring the Albertsons and Acme chains from SUPERVALU (NYSE:SVU) for $3.3 billion.
Of the three, however, I see Ahold as perhaps the best bet. It sold its stake in a Swedish grocery chain for $3.1 billion, but it's expanding its presence in the U.S. and likes to buy local stores to do so. That would mesh well with the image of A&P and would seem a good fit. Ahold was also thought of as a potential buyer of Harris Teeter before Kroger stepped in, so buying A&P might be a worthy complement to its Stop & Shop chain, which also has a heavy presence in the Northeast. It might allow it to keep the best of the stores going while shedding the dreck that still remains in the 300-plus-store chain.
Kroger's getting a lot of headline play out of the speculation, but I don't see it as the ultimate winner here.
Fool contributor Rich Duprey has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of SUPERVALU. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.