Has American Capital Mortgage (NASDAQ:MTGE) found calm waters in choppy markets, or is it stuck in the doldrums?
That's the question I'm left asking after the company reported earnings on Wednesday. The presentation revealed that American Capital Mortgage is making big moves to insulate its portfolio from rising rates.
Here are two ways it's mixing things up:
1. Hello, 15-year mortgages
Like its sister mortgage REIT American Capital Agency (NASDAQ:AGNC), American Capital Mortgage moved its portfolio to moderate its duration. The company slashed 30-year mortgages, added to 15-year mortgages, and initiated a new position in adjustable-rate mortgage-backed securities in its agency portfolio.
Here's a quick quarter-over-quarter portfolio composition comparison:
Fifteen-year mortgages have become the new safe haven for American Capital Agency and American Capital Mortgage. American Capital Agency once noted in a shareholder presentation that holding 15-year mortgages at nine times leverage is similar to holding 30-year mortgages at six times leverage.
Fifteen-year mortgages are inherently safer when interest rates rise because they have less convexity risk -- 15-year mortgages don't move as much as 30-year mortgages when rates rise or fall.
Obviously, this additional layer of safety comes at a cost. American Capital Mortgage's 15-year MBSes offer much lower yields than 30-year agency paper.
Securities with fewer than 15 years to maturity yield only 3.12% compared to fatter 3.57% yields on longer-dated paper, according to the earnings presentation. However, much like American Capital Agency, American Capital Mortgage is willing to give up lower returns for some book value protection. That might not be a bad idea if interest rates tick higher.
2. Welcome aboard, mortgage servicing rights
The most interesting development at American Capital Mortgage is its move to acquire Residential Credit Solutions, a mortgage loan servicer. Other mREITs like Two Harbors (NYSE:TWO) have acquired similar assets as a way to generate a return and hedge their mortgage portfolios.
At a JMP Securities Presentation with analysts, Two Harbors' Chief Investment Officer Bill Roth had nothing but praise for mortgage servicing rights, saying, "We're very excited about it because MSR provides us an [interest-only] like cash flow that not only throws off an attractive yield, but also hedges not only interest rate risk but also mortgage basis risk."
Currently, mREITs pay money to hedge their portfolios. MSRs provide a hedge that pays the mREIT -- a win-win situation.
Without word from American Capital Mortgage, there's not yet a way to know how big this acquisition really is. An earlier and unrelated press release from Fitch notes that Residential Credit Solutions had a portfolio of "credit-sensitive and servicing-intensive residential mortgage assets" worth as much as $8.2 billion. However, it's not clear from a high-level view who owns the assets or how Residential Credit Solutions has a financial interest in those MSRs. We likely won't know until the deal is finalized, but it will be interesting to watch how American Capital Mortgage builds these assets into its balance sheet.
In a volatile interest rate environment, MSRs can provide book value insulation and cash flow for hybrid, go-anywhere REITs like Two Harbors and American Capital Mortgage.
Why American Capital Mortgage's strategy matters
What's truly remarkable about the quarter is that American Capital Mortgage performed much better than one would have expected after American Capital Agency's relatively poor quarter.
The company managed to eke out $0.85 in non-GAAP taxable income, which more than covers its $0.70 quarterly dividend, thanks mostly to profitable hedges.
Additionally, it has $0.60 per share in undistributed taxable income, which can buy it time to continue paying its current quarterly dividend.
The Foolish bottom line
All in all, American Capital Mortgage evaded most of the worst in the third quarter. Its efforts to move into 15-year mortgages didn't come at the cost of its dividend. And with $0.58 in net spread income, it isn't entirely earning its dividend from interest, but it's pretty darn close -- much closer than American Capital Agency.
Fool contributor Jordan Wathen has no position in any stocks mentioned, and neither does The Motley Fool. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.