The Big Board transformed itself in 2006. After 213 years as a private club, it became a public company, the NYSE Group
For 2007, NYSE is in a good position to improve its operating and financial results dramatically.
In 2006, Thain and his team implemented their Euronext merger strategy astutely, and with political finesse -- in contrast to the more warrior-like approach of Nasdaq
As French political and financial opposition evaporates, and the fear of a U.S. regulatory spillover dissolves, the Euronext merger looks near-certain. The revised 802-page prospectus for the merger, issued in November, is clear on the main source of value from the merger. Of the projected annualized cost savings of $275 million, $250 million comes from consolidating technology systems, projected to be realized over three years -- $30 million in 2007, $100 million in 2008, and $250 million in 2009.
The NYSE Euronext group will start life with three cash trading platforms, including Hybrid and NYSE Arca, and three derivative platforms. The plan is to move to one cash system and one derivative system. The most likely candidate for the single cash platform is NSC -- so the new Hybrid system may have a very short life. The NSC system, developed by Euronext, is a battle-tested system at the heart of several major U.S. exchanges. It is licensed to the Chicago Mercantile Exchange
Projected savings from the merger also include $25 million a year for non-IT cost savings. Additional revenue synergies of $100 million are projected, with expected realization within three years of the combination.
Now, on to valuation. Given the zoom in exchange stocks this year, valuing NYSE relative to other exchange stocks requires caution -- they are all very high. NYSE trades at a forward P/E of 44, Nymex Holdings has the same ratio, and the CME has a forward ratio of 36. Relative to its sector, NYSE represents the best value for two reasons. First, it has the greatest scope for improvement -- current operating margins of 30% are less than half those of Nymex and CME. Second, NYSE, with its proposed Euronext merger, has the most ambitious and highest-return strategy. Orchestrating the first-ever transatlantic exchange is much higher-risk than knocking exchanges together in Chicago. But NYSE now has a track record with the successful Archipelago integration -- or, as some argue, the other way around -- and can call on Euronext's proven expertise in cross-border mergers.
Fool contributor John Finneran writes and advises on increasing the financial value of technology. He is currently ranked 47 out of 17,758 in CAPS and does not own any of the shares mentioned. The Fool's disclosure policy will trade you its peanut butter sandwich for your Twinkie.