A short-sighted market often creates a profit opportunity.
When the masses seem to be looking at raw numbers and not the meaning behind those numbers, that can mean opportunities for individual investors to exploit. Such seems to be the case with Hibbett Sports
Like its competitors, Big 5 Sporting Goods
Yet after reporting 25% sales growth and a commensurate 27% increase in earnings for the last quarter of fiscal 2007 -- yeah, we've mentioned before the oddity of Hibbett's fiscal year -- the southeast U.S.-based sporting goods company said fickle fiscal years could be a problem. It cautioned that investors should expect to see earnings below forecasts for the first quarter of 2008. Where analysts were expecting earnings of $0.41 per share on projected revenues of $145 million, Hibbett's own guidance said earnings will instead be in the range of $0.32 to $0.35 per share. As a result, the company's shares were driven down more than 8% in pre-market trading.
How is that meaningful for investors? While there does appear to be a slight weakness to the guidance, there are a couple of factors at play here. First is the fact that fiscal year 2007 had an extra selling week in it. While that obviously helped the fourth quarter's numbers, it also detracts from the next quarter's results. The shift in that one week alone is expected to impact earnings by $0.02 to $0.03 per share. It also serves to move approximately $0.02 per share of stock compensation expense out of the fourth quarter and into the first.
Those two items add $0.05 per share to Hibbett's guidance, and you now have a forecast of around $0.40 per share, which is just shy of analyst projections. So is it a little weak? Sure, but perhaps not worth the $74 million loss of market cap the pre-market trading would suggest.
Hibbett has been a fairly consistent performer, although it has experienced flagging same-store sales at times. That held it back last year, but also factors into first-quarter planning. On a fiscal-year basis, Hibbett expects a 1% to 3% decline in same-store sales. On a calendar-year basis, however, it sees a 2% increase. Same-store sales measure sales at stores open for more than a year, and while this is an important metric for the retail industry, it should not be viewed exclusive of other factors.
For that reason, Hibbett believes comparing the projected first half of 2008 with last year's first half is a more meaningful comparison than just looking at individual quarters. While management often looks to put the best face on a situation -- you can be sure if Hibbett was expecting blowout numbers next quarter they'd be trumpeting them instead of shifting the outlook -- there's at least some sense to the company's reasoning.
On a half-year basis, then, the sporting goods retailer's earnings of $0.54 to $0.57 per share compared to the $0.47 per share earned in the year-ago half, while also expecting 4% growth in comparable sales.
Hibbett had a relatively strong fourth quarter, and the first half of the year typically generates less than half of the company's revenues. Also, there are seasonal factors affecting the coming first quarter. All this makes me think the sell-off in Hibbett's stock represents an opportunity for investors.
For more on companies that peddle products for players, check out:
More from The Motley Fool
Why National Beverage, Dycom, and Hibbett Sports Jumped Today
Find out what sent these stocks higher in a strong market.
Why Shares of Hibbett Sports, Inc. Popped 27% Today
An earnings beat is good, but there are some concerning signs for Hibbett Sports, Inc. long-term.
Why Hibbett Sports Stock Plunged 21% in August
The besieged sporting goods retailer suffered through another brutal month following its second-quarter earnings release.