You have to admire Advanced Micro Devices (NYSE:AMD). Despite being a much smaller company without a seemingly limitless supply of greenbacks, it's been able to more than hold its own against Intel (NASDAQ:INTC) in the PC chips war.

Yes, AMD and Intel were born joined at the fist, and we love to pit one against the other. This week, we'll sidestep Intel -- a popular Motley Fool Inside Value stock pick -- and focus on AMD.

What's the secret to AMD's success? Can it reward faithful investors? Not all Fools agree. Anders Bylund is bullish on the company's prospects, while Tim Beyers feels the company's got a long road ahead of it.

Where do you stand?