Over the past 5 years, Bank of America's (NYSE:BAC) stock has been one of the more polarizing investments on the market. Some investors got burned during the financial crisis and hate the stock. Other investors sing its praises and sit on nearly 200% gains over the past 16 months.
But where does the stock stand today? Has all of the upside been pumped into the share price or is there still room to run on the upside?
To gauge the value of Bank of America shares today, we asked seven Fools to weigh in with their opinion on the stock's attractiveness today.
Brendan Mathews: Bank of America is a buy today.
Its investors have faced an almost constant barrage of bad news over the past five years, and the bad news hasn't stopped -- the company is currently facing a litany of legal suits that could cost the bank billions. In this atmosphere of negativity, it's easy to lose track of the long-term picture, which is that Bank of America is a dominant franchise. It has over a trillion in deposits, on which it pays very little interest, that are a huge source of value.
Last year, it generated a return on equity of only 4%, but I don't think that's indicative of the bank's long-term potential for profitability. Over the long-term, Bank of America should be able to generate double-digit returns on equity, which would justify the company trading at book value or higher (a significant premium to today's multiple of 0.75x book).
John Maxfield: Two years ago, I agreed with Brendan and thought Bank of America was a buy. But today, I believe it's a hold.
While its trading group, Global Markets struggled a touch in terms of profitability, combined, these four businesses delivered a return on average allocated capital -- Bank of America's measure for how profitable its businesses are -- of roughly 17.5%. Put simply, its core operations are phenomenally profitable.
Undeniably, its fifth unit, Consumer Real Estate Services, still deals with the mess it made as a result of the mortgage fiasco and corresponding crisis which causes massive headache. But when you consider Bank of America still trades at a remarkably low 1.2 price-to-tangible book value multiple, it means when the past finally passes, it's poised for great things.
Matthew Frankel: Patrick is right. Bank of America is a long-term buy.
It's true it has a giant pending legal settlement which will end up costing between $12 billion and $17 billion, and that $5 billion of "wiggle room" definitely creates some uncertainty. This could produce considerable volatility in the short-term, but as a business, Bank of America is pretty solid and improving nicely.
The consumer banking unit is cutting costs and growing deposits, and the brokerage business is doing extremely well. It's taken longer than anyone would have hoped to put the mortgage crisis in the past, but it will happen sooner rather than later.
David Hanson: I think Bank of America is buy in today's market, but it depends on how long you are willing to wait for the returns. I don't question that a combination of multiple expansion and book value growth can boost shares higher, but it may take longer than most are willing to wait.
Bank of America's future profitability is heavily dependent on strong loan underwriting, and more importantly, a steeper yield curve to drive more interest income. I, like most, believe this will happen, but it may take several years for that to happen. Even if you think shares have 30% upside before they reach a "fair value," if it that takes 10 years, you're annualized returns will sit below 3%. To me, 3% per year is not an adequate return for a company (in its current form) that doesn't have a history of thriving through a credit downturn.
That said, I don't imagine it taking 10 years to achieve these returns. I think 2 to 4 years is more reasonable, which would fetch investors an annualized return of roughly 10% per year.
Kingkarn Amjareon: Bank of America is a central pillar of the U.S. financial system. Though the bank is one of the largest in the world and has attractive long-term earnings prospects, legal issues continue to haunt the bank.
Resurfacing litigation and settlement risks cloud Bank of America's true earnings power and lead investors to stay away from the bank despite a persistently low valuation.
With a 25% discount to book value, Bank of America offers a healthy margin of safety and remains an asymmetric bet on a solidifying recovery of the U.S. economy. The stock is a buy.
Wayne Duggan: We're starting to sound like a broken-record, but Bank of America is a buy.
The legal issues and recent "accounting errors" that resulted in a suspension of the proposed dividend and buyback plans have spooked shareholders, and the stock is being punished more than is due.
The $4 billion accounting error prompted Morgan Stanley analysts to lower their 2015 EPS estimate by only 1.3%, while the 2014 estimates remained unchanged. With that 1.2 price-to-tangible book value mutliple, Bank of America is trading at a significant discount to most of its peers, indicating that all the legal uncertainty seems to already be priced into the stock.
Of the seven Fools we surveyed, five of them are very bullish on shares of Bank of America, one is moderately bullish, and one believes the stock is a "hold" at current prices.
Brendan Mathews, Matthew Frankel, David Hanson and John Maxfield have no position in any stocks mentioned. Kingkarn Amjaroen owns shares of Bank of America. Patrick Morris owns shares of Bank of America and US Bancorp. Wayne Duggan owns shares of Bank of America and Wells Fargo. The Motley Fool recommends Bank of America and Wells Fargo. The Motley Fool owns shares of Bank of America and Wells Fargo. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.