Weight Watchers (WW -5.39%) suffers from oversized expectations.
Since Oprah Winfrey bought 10% of the company last October, investors have expected its numbers to pop. Instead, while things may be looking up, there has been no massive "Oprah effect," and that has caused the market to punish the company's shares.
What: After posting solid if uninspiring Q1 numbers on May 4, shares in the company rose, but the effect wore off quickly. Once the calendar turned to June, it was a fairly steady downward fall for the company's share price.
After closing May 31 at $15.16, shares finished June at $11.63, a 23% drop, according to data from S&P Global Market Intelligence.
So what: Weight Watchers had a good May, paced by its Q1 results and the fact that it raised its guidance for the year. CEO Jim Chambers was upbeat in the earnings release.
Leveraging the success of our new Beyond the Scale program, we expect to deliver revenue and profit growth for the full year 2016, and we are raising our earnings guidance to a range of $0.80 to $1.05 per share...Our first-quarter loss was smaller than we expected, and for the first time since 2012 we grew our total subscribers year over year, clearly demonstrating that our business is turning around.
That sounds good, and for a while investors were on board, but since Winfrey's involvement, any optimism turned into people expecting miracles.
Now what: Ultimately, the investing public will stop expecting overnight success and actually reward the fact that Weight Watchers has been gaining members. If the company can continue to do that and meet its new guidance, then eventually it should be judged on its merits -- not on the fact that a celebrity bought a stake in the company and joined its board.
Winfrey hasn't been a miracle worker since she stopped having a daily talk show as a platform. That said, she does have an audience and has shown an ability to build products over the long term. There's no reason to believe that won't happen here and eventually this stock will recover.