Shares of mobile chip giant Qualcomm (NASDAQ:QCOM) tumbled 18.3% in January, according to data provided by S&P Global Market Intelligence. A one-two punch of legal actions was the culprit, with the Federal Trade Commission charging the company with anti-competitive practices and Apple suing over patent royalty issues.
On Jan. 17, the FTC filed a complaint in federal district court charging Qualcomm with anti-competitive behavior. The FTC is accusing Qualcomm of using its dominant position as a supplier of baseband processors to extract onerous supply and licensing terms from phone manufacturers.
The FTC alleged that Qualcomm uses a "no license, no chips" policy which withholds chips from phone manufacturers if they fail to agree with Qualcomm's license terms. The FTC believes this is effectively an anti-competitive tax on the use of rivals' chips. Qualcomm is also accused of refusing to license standard-essential patents.
Apple sued Qualcomm three days later, followed by another lawsuit in China. The iPhone giant accused Qualcomm of charging royalties for technologies that it had nothing to do with, effectively raising the cost of new features. According to Apple, it pays Qualcomm five times more in royalties than all other cellular patent licensors combined. Apple also accused Qualcomm of withholding $1 billion in payments in retaliation for cooperating with law enforcement agencies.
Qualcomm has disputed the FTC complaint and called the Apple lawsuit baseless, but any threat to Qualcomm's lucrative licensing business should be taken seriously by investors. During Qualcomm's first quarter, the licensing business generated $1.52 billion of pre-tax profit, compared to just $724 million for the chip business.
How these lawsuits turn out is anyone's guess, and it will likely take quite a while for decisions to be made. It's also unclear whether these suits will affect Qualcomm's acquisition of NXP Semiconductors, which is scheduled to close before the end of the year. Investors pushed down the stock in January to account for these added risks, erasing a good portion of last year's gains.