At long last, online radio streamer Pandora Media (NYSE:P) is finally ready to launch its on-demand offering, Pandora Premium. The new service, which was announced in December but is just now launching, will cost $10 and Pandora says it will "change the way you listen to music." Considering the fact that Pandora Premium largely replicates what other $10-per-month, on-demand music streaming services offer, that's unlikely. There are 40 million songs in the catalog, which is comparable to the two big heavyweights; Apple (NASDAQ:AAPL) Music also has 40 million songs while Spotify advertises 30 million.
Pandora Premium will also include Pandora's flagship online radio service that creates stations based on personal preferences. This is a feature that Apple Music and Spotify also offer, although Pandora was the first mover. It's less clear which company has the best algorithm for this, or if users place much value on personalized radio relative to the on-demand aspect.
Can Pandora Premium make a dent against Apple Music and Spotify?
Hopping on the on-demand bandwagon
At last count, Apple said in December it had 20 million paid subscribers. Earlier this month, Spotify said it had reached over 50 million subscribers, or about half of its total active user base of 100 million, which includes ad-supported users that use the service for free. The music-streaming industry has been rapidly shifting toward paid and on-demand; paid for the benefit of the industry's economics, and on-demand because consumers like to choose specific songs to listen to.
Spotify may be the market leader in terms of paid subscribers, but Apple Music could be the industry's preferred service since the Mac maker only offers a paid option with no ad-supported tier. According to Pandora's most recent 10-K, it had approximately 4.4 million paid subscribers at the end of 2016, or just 5% of the company's total 81 million active users across all services.
But at what cost?
The pressure will now be on to grow Pandora Premium's subscriber base, since Pandora's cost structure is changing as a result. Specifically, Pandora is on the hook for unspecified minimum payments:
In addition, to support the launch of these services we have entered into direct license agreements with the major record labels, which agreements entail substantial minimum guaranteed content acquisition cost payments by us. There is no assurance that we will be able to successfully develop and launch Pandora Premium, or obtain and maintain the content license rights to enable the offering of Pandora Plus and Pandora Premium. Further, in a number of cases, our direct license agreements with record labels require that we launch an on-demand subscription offering, and the rates for content acquisition costs payable under certain of our direct license agreements with record labels are significantly affected by the number of subscribers we are able to attract and retain to our subscription services, including Pandora Premium.
It's notable that some of the licenses require Pandora to get into on-demand, more evidence that the industry would highly prefer that model.
Throughout Pandora's history, it streamed content based upon statutory licenses created by the Digital Performance Right in Sound Recordings Act of 1995 and the Digital Millennium Copyright Act of 1998 that typically apply to terrestrial radio stations, which earned the ire of much of the music industry. That's why it was such a big deal when Pandora inked direct licensing agreements with major record labels last September ahead of Pandora Premium's unveiling. Pandora said last month that it took just six months to ink these deals.
It's good that Pandora is finally getting into the on-demand streaming market, since that's where consumers are gravitating, but it's also probably too little, too late.
Evan Niu, CFA owns shares of Apple. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends Apple and Pandora Media. The Motley Fool has the following options: long January 2018 $90 calls on Apple and short January 2018 $95 calls on Apple. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.