Editas Medicine (NASDAQ:EDIT) and Sangamo Therapeutics (NASDAQ:SGMO) have quite a bit in common. Both biotechs are pioneers of gene editing. Both have attracted partnerships with big drugmakers. Both stocks soared earlier in 2018. And both Editas and Sangamo gave up all of those gains and then some.
But these biotechs remain intriguing candidates for investors looking to the future. Which stock is the better choice now? Here's how Editas Medicine and Sangamo Therapeutics compare.
The case for Editas Medicine
Promising technology targeting diseases with a significant unmet medical need. That's the argument for investing in Editas Medicine in a nutshell.
The promising technology for Editas is CRISPR, which stands for clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats. This gene-editing approach has been called "the biggest biotech discovery of the century." And Editas Medicine ranks as one of the leading biotechs developing CRISPR-based therapies.
Editas licensed patents from Broad Institute for CRISPR-Cas9 and CRISPR-Cpf1 enzymes that hold the potential to directly edit close to 95% of the human genome. Those patents have been successfully defended in the U.S., which puts Editas in a great position from an intellectual property perspective.
The biotech's lead candidate, EDIT-101, is a CRISPR gene-editing therapy targeting Leber congenital amaurosis type 10 (LCA10), the top cause of inherited childhood blindness that currently has no approved treatment. Editas and partner Allergan filed an application with the FDA in October to begin a phase 1/2 clinical study of EDIT-101.
Editas plans to leverage its expertise gained with EDIT-101 to treat other rare genetic eye diseases as well. The company is conducting preclinical testing using a similar approach to target Usher syndrome type 2a (USH2A).
Celgene is working with Editas to develop engineered T cells for fighting cancer. The two biotechs have several product candidates that could advance through the pipeline.
Editas is also excited about the potential for its CRISPR gene-editing therapies targeting the genetic blood disorders sickle cell disease and beta-thalassemia. The biotech is presenting preclinical data for these therapies at the upcoming American Society of Hematology (ASH) annual meeting.
The case for Sangamo Therapeutics
The main investing thesis for Sangamo Therapeutics is similar to the one for Editas. Sangamo is using different technologies, but they're promising -- and they target diseases with significant unmet medical need.
Sangamo uses zinc-finger nuclease (ZFN) technology to edit genes. It's the oldest gene-editing approach, which means that it's had more time to build confidence in the scientific community. While several biotechs are using CRISPR, Sangamo is the only one focused on ZFN.
The company claims three ZFN gene-editing therapies in phase 1/2 clinical testing. One targets hemophilia type B, while the other two focus on the rare genetic metabolic diseases mucopolysaccharidosis type I (MPS I) and mucopolysaccharidosis type II (MPS II).
Bioverativ, which was acquired by Sanofi earlier this year, teamed up with Sangamo to develop ZFN-based cell therapies for treating beta thalassemia and sickle cell disease. Gilead Sciences is also working with Sangamo on preclinical testing of cell therapies for treating cancer.
Unlike Editas, Sangamo also is developing gene therapies, which insert a gene into cells to correct genetic mutations rather than editing the genes. Pfizer partnered with Sangamo on hemophilia A gene therapy SB-525, which has some promising preliminary results from a phase 1/2 clinical study in August.
Sangamo has several preclinical programs in its pipeline focused on other rare diseases as well. It's developing a gene-editing therapy targeting neurodegenerative disorders called tauopathies. The biotech is conducting preclinical testing for a cell therapy to be used in solid-organ transplants. And it's evaluating an experimental gene therapy for treating Fabry disease.
Which of these two biotech stocks is the better buy? The right answer for most investors is...neither of them.
It's still very early for both Editas and Sangamo. There's no guarantee that either company will be successful. Too much could go wrong. Sangamo, for example, has already reported disappointing results for its MPS II gene-editing therapy. Editas faces worries about potential risks with CRISPR.
But I think that both Editas and Sangamo should be on the radar screens for aggressive investors. Sangamo is farther along and has more shots on goal, so some investors might prefer to play the odds and go with it. My personal pick is Editas because I think it probably has the broader range of genomic targets -- in other words, more potential diseases its technology could treat.
Either biotech stock is a risky bet, but either bet could also pay off in a huge way down the road. I'm betting on Editas for now.