CarMax (KMX 0.04%) turned into a one-car pileup Thursday, falling 19.7% through 2:15 p.m. ET after reporting worse-than-expected earnings for its fiscal second quarter, ended Aug. 31.
Heading into the report, analysts forecast a strong quarter for the used car dealer, with earnings of $1.03 per share on $7 billion in sales. Instead, CarMax's profit was only $0.64 per share, and sales were only $6.6 billion.
Image source: Getty Images.
CarMax Q2 earnings
Year over year, sales sank 6%, worse than the company's 5.4% decline in retail sales, indicative of both weaker customer demand and lower prices. Wholesale sales, however, declined only 2.2% -- so part of the relative weakness in revenue may stem from CarMax making more lower-priced wholesale sales and fewer lucrative retail sales.
Overall car demand, though, also appears to be weakening, with CarMax buying 2.4% fewer cars for resale -- indicative of where management sees market demand heading.
Profits plunged 25% year over year, instead of growing as analysts had hoped they would.
Is CarMax stock a buy?
CEO Bill Nash admitted Q2 was "challenging," but insisted that despite the steep decline in profits, he's still "confident in our long-term strategy and the strength of the earnings model." Just to be safe, though, he's cutting selling, general, and administrative spending by $150 million over the next 18 months.
Personally, I'm not sure he's right to be optimistic.
At $6.9 billion in market capitalization and with $521 million in trailing profit, CarMax doesn't look too expensive at just 13.2 times earnings. With analysts forecasting 16% long-term earnings growth, that should make CarMax stock a good value. Problem is, analysts just got caught flat-footed predicting earnings growth -- and were surprised by the 25% earnings decline.
If this keeps up, even as cheap as it looks, CarMax stock could be a sell.
