Earlier this month, while suggesting that Fools not go overboard with energy equities, I voiced my concern that oil and the stock market were becoming uncomfortably correlated. This suggested to me that price signals were breaking down, and that poor capital allocation decisions would be made as a result.
My comments on correlation were based on simple observation of day-to-day market behavior, and I didn't have any hard numbers for you. Bloomberg has since performed a study that confirms my hunch.
Based on percentage changes over a trailing 60-day period, correlations between the S&P 500 and the Reuters/Jefferies CRB Index (a basket of various commodities) hit a high of 0.74 this month. That's the tightest correlation seen in at least 50 years. The correlation between stocks and crude oil alone also topped 0.7 (or 70% in percentage terms).
It made a good bit of sense for assets of all sorts to move in tandem when the market tanked. From ordinary investors to executives at companies like Chesapeake Energy
The recent pile-on in equities, commodities, and emerging markets -- through both individual securities and exchange-traded funds like the U.S. Natural Gas Fund
While the indiscriminate selling was forced to some degree, nothing's compelling today's purchases, other than perhaps a desperation to claw back some of 2008's massive losses. From an institutional money manager's point of view, perhaps the only thing worse than losing half your clients' money would be to do so and then sit out the ensuing rally. You'd lose even more of your assets under management, and maybe even your job.
In gambling, the attempt to win back losses is called "chasing." There's more than a bit of that happening in the markets today, and it makes this Fool extremely uneasy.
Fool contributor Toby Shute doesn't have a position in any company mentioned. Check out his CAPS profile or follow his articles using Twitter or RSS. Chesapeake Energy is an Inside Value selection. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
More from The Motley Fool
Saudi Shake-Up Sent Oil Stocks Soaring Today
Several beaten-down oil companies jumped double digits after crude spiked on a wave of arrests in Saudi Arabia that suggested the kingdom’s oil policy won’t change.
Why Chesapeake Energy, Cavium, and Advanced Micro Devices Jumped Today
Find out about the catalysts that sent these stocks higher.
This Is What Drove Chesapeake Energy Corporation's Double-Digit Drop in October
Analysts didn’t like what they saw when they compared the natural gas giant to other shale drillers.