In the annals of corporate history, I'm guessing that AT&T's
But instead, AT&T has exclusive distribution rights that last at least into 2010, and as its Q3 earnings release shows, that shiny little device has been quite the saving grace for the company.
Coming in at $0.54 per share, AT&T's earnings beat analyst estimates by $0.04 per share, and the wireless division clearly deserves most of the credit. Driven by 3.2 million iPhone activations, net subscriber additions topped 2 million, well ahead of the consensus estimate of 1.5 million, and very impressive for a country where the wireless penetration rate is now above 90%. Wireless service revenue grew by 10% annually, and over the same time, the Wireless division's operating margin soared from 18.9% to 24.6%.
What's more, with the cheapest iPhone plan costing $70/month, AT&T's average revenue per user grew by $2.24 annually, to $61.23. And with every iPhone user a data-services subscriber, data revenue managed to grow by 33% annually, to account for more than 26% of total wireless revenues.
But, alas, AT&T isn't merely a wireless service provider. The company also has a wireline division that still accounts for the majority of its revenue. And this division depends on a local phone business that's slowly unraveling, as consumers and businesses ditch their traditional landlines either for cellular connections or cheaper voice over Internet protocol (VoIP) connections from the likes of Comcast
AT&T has long touted its U-verse initiative for offering a "triple play" of VoIP, Internet, and TV services as its answer to dealing with the nonstop decline in traditional voice revenues. But while some initial progress has been made -- there are now more than 1.8 million U-verse TV subscribers -- much more work needs to be done, considering that AT&T lost nearly 1 million consumer phone lines last quarter. But instead of accelerating the pace of U-verse deployments, AT&T seems to be slowing things down, with net additions to TV subscribers up only 8,000 from the pace set last quarter.
The slowdown in the U-verse build -- likely a major reason why AT&T's 2009 capital expenditures are down considerably from 2008 -- has helped boost the company's free cash flow over the short term. AT&T badly needs that cash to keep trimming its massive debt load, which still stood near $73 billion at the end of Q3. But it's also likely to hurt the wireline division's profitability over the long run, since it gives cable and wireless service providers more time to woo away AT&T's local phone customers.
Without a surge in U-verse sign-ups, the wireline division's revenue and profit declines could easily continue for years to come. And if AT&T's exclusivity agreement for the iPhone ends next year, it won't be long before the wireless division is no longer able to offset wireline's weakness.