Not long ago, Ouya represented a potentially disruptive threat to console gaming. The affordable $99 gaming console that was looking to borrow from mobile platforms in more ways than one had serious potential to hurt Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT) and Sony (NYSE:SNE) just as they prepare to release their respective next-generation consoles.

Instead of using bleeding-edge hardware coupled with a licensing model, Ouya opted for modest mobile ingredients typically found in smartphones and embraced Google (NASDAQ:GOOGL) Android for its extensive library of existing games. Ouya is also betting big on the freemium model, requiring developers to offer a free version of all games with the hopes that gamers will pay up for additional content of virtual goods.

Sadly, Ouya isn't living up to those lofty expectations. For most of the early developers that made the plunge to port their games to Ouya, it hasn't moved the needle in any meaningful way, according to a new report from IGN. Some developers are enjoying success, and fortunately Android games are extremely easy to port since Ouya runs on Google's platform.

There haven't been any blockbusters, though, and there aren't any exclusive titles that can convince customers to buy Ouya. The small company has recently launched a Free The Games Fund, putting up $1 million to match Kickstarter pledges, with the hopes of getting some exclusive content. Ouya had plenty left over after it was Kickstarted, since it overshot its goal by $7.6 million, so it's giving some back to the Kickstarter community.

Ouya's biggest weakness is the overall quality of titles available, with some already straining the NVIDIA Tegra 3 processor inside. The Motley Fool's senior tech analyst, Fool Eric Bleeker, also wasn't overly impressed with the console's execution, since the hardware isn't top-notch and the available titles are similarly mediocre.

Microsoft has already sold out of Xbox One preorders, after it reversed course on its initial strategy. Following Microsoft's early backlash, Sony had increased its internal forecast for the PlayStation 4, and there's no word to whether or not the Japanese company subsequently reduced its estimates after Microsoft's reversal.

As the Xbox One and PlayStation 4 prepare to hit the market later this year, Microsoft and Sony can rest assured that the Ouya won't be stealing sales.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium advisory service. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis -- even one of our own -- helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer.