HIV, the virus that causes AIDS, has become one of the world's most devastating diseases since it was first recognized more than three decades ago. 33.4 million people across the world are infected with HIV, and 1.15 million of those live in the United States. To date, there is no cure for the disease, which leads to the progressive failure of the immune system, although current treatments are now much more advanced than Retrovir (AZT) -- the first approved HIV medication, which had marginal benefits and a terrible side effect profile.
Today's leading biotech companies focusing on HIV treatments are Gilead Sciences (NASDAQ:GILD), GlaxoSmithKline (NYSE:GSK), and Merck (NYSE:MRK), and each of these companies has a unique approach to handling HIV to prevent it from becoming full-blown AIDS. Let's take a look at the evolution of HIV treatments over the past three decades to understand how these drugs work and which company's treatments are the most promising.
The evolution of HIV treatments
Retrovir, which was approved in 1987, is a nucleoside analog reverse transcriptase inhibitor (NRTI). NRTIs were followed up by nucleotide analog reverse transcriptase inhibitors (NtRTIs), such as Gilead Sciences' best-selling HIV treatment, Viread, which was approved in 2001. NTRIs and NtRTIs both focus on blocking reverse transcriptase, a critical virus enzyme found in HIV-1 and hepatitis-B virus infections.
Nucleotide analog treatments like Viread are considered more efficient than nucleoside analog ones like Retrovir, since Retrovir relies on the body to convert nucleoside to nucleotide. Viread simply skips that conversion step altogether.
Gilead's endless combo strategy
Gilead Sciences, now the largest producer of HIV treatments in the world, attributes much of its success to Viread sales. Today, Viread has been overshadowed by two more important treatments: Truvada and Atripla. Viread sales still accounted for 9% of Gilead's sales in 2012, but Truvada accounted for 23% while Atripla generated 37% of its total revenue.
These three drugs, however, are not as unique they appear. Truvada is a combination of Viread and Emtriva (emtricitabine), another NtRTI from Gilead, combined into a single fixed-dose pill. Atripla goes a step further by combining Truvada with Merck's Sustiva (efavirenz), a non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor, into a new fixed-dose pill. Last September, it followed that up by introducing Stribild, which combines the two active ingredients of Truvada with EVG (a newer integrase inhibitor) and cobicistat, which increases the potency of the combination by inhibiting liver enzymes.
Because of this habit of combining existing drugs into new ones, Gilead is often accused of "evergreening" its products to avoid upcoming patent expirations, such as the upcoming expirations of Sustiva and Viread in 2013 and 2018, respectively. Gilead is also criticized for the price of its drugs -- Stribild is the most expensive HIV treatment on the market, costing $28,500 per patient annually. Sales of Stribild rose 8% sequentially last quarter to $99.4 million.
However, these combination drugs (known as triple or quad pills) are useful for HIV patients who don't want to take multiple medications daily. Gilead's strategy is also a widely accepted one, and approximately 72% of HIV patients have been treated by one of the company's medications. As a result, Gilead's earnings and revenue rose 8.6% and 15.1% year-on-year last quarter.
Here come the new challengers
Tivicay (dolutegravir), which was created by ViiV Healthcare, was recently approved by the FDA as an HIV treatment. ViiV Healthcare is a joint venture between Glaxo, Pfizer and Shionogi & Co. Glaxo is the majority shareholder, with a 76.5% stake. Unlike Retrovir and Viread, Tivicay is an integrase inhibitor, a new type of HIV drug.
Integrase inhibitors block integrase, a viral enzyme which inserts the viral genome into the host cell's DNA. Blocking integrase cripples the cell's ability to replicate, thus halting the spread of HIV and possibly other retroviruses. Only two other integrase inhibitors have been approved for the treatment of HIV: Gilead Sciences' EVG (elvitegravir) and Merck's Isentress (raltegravir). EVG is only approved as a sub-component of other drugs, and not a stand-alone treatment, while Isentress is approved for both. Tivicay and Isentress are not potent enough on their own and must be prescribed with other HIV medications.
Analysts polled by Thomson Reuters believe that Tivicay sales could reach $900 million by 2017, but it won't comprise a significant part of Glaxo's annual revenue, which came in at nearly $40 billion last year. Isentress generated $1.5 billion in 2012 sales, rising 11% year-on-year and accounting for 3.2% of Merck's total revenue, suggesting robust demand for integrase inhibitors in the future.
During clinical trials, Tivicay performed favorably when compared to Isentress and Atripla. Tivicay's side effects were generally mild, including insomnia and headache. However, serious liver problems could occur in patients with hepatitis B or C infections.
A Foolish final thought
For investors searching for the best biotech bet on HIV treatments, Gilead Sciences is the obvious choice. The company's dominant treatments, its talent for combining older treatments into newer, more potent ones, and its solid top and bottom line growth all indicate that it is a robust long-term investment.
Yet, Gilead Sciences is considered a growth stock for these reasons, and it trades with a forward P/E of 19 -- a loftier valuation than Glaxo and Merck, which both trade at 13 times forward earnings. Gilead also doesn't pay a dividend, while Glaxo and Merck have yields of 4.3% and 3.6%, respectively.
Although Glaxo and Merck's recent progress with integrase inhibitors is encouraging, this new class of drugs is unlikely to displace traditional reverse transcriptase inhibitors any time soon. Rather, they should be regarded as complementary treatments, which will be prescribed alongside other established HIV treatments -- most likely produced by Gilead Sciences.
Leo Sun has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Gilead Sciences. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
More from The Motley Fool
No Holiday Reprieve for 2 of the Biggest Retail Train Wrecks
Most department store chains have posted surprisingly strong results for the 2017 holiday season. However, these perennial laggards couldn't capitalize on the uptick in consumer spending.
3 Stocks That Could Put Amazon's Returns to Shame
These three tickers could be better bets than Amazon for new investors right now.
Will This iPhone Supplier’s Terrific Run Continue in 2018?
Lumentum's growing momentum in 3D sensing could help it overcome the weakness in the telecom segment.