Mr. Market has not been kind to Pandora Media (NYSE:P)as of late. After reporting improvements in both listener hours, a higher share of the U.S. radio market, and a year-over-year increase in active listeners, shareholders took concern that the business's growth might be slowing. In response to the news, combined with a general decline in the S&P 500, shares of the Internet radio broadcast company contracted 10%. Is it possible that Mr. Market is overreacting to Pandora's news and that it's still alive and well, or could these metrics suggest tougher times ahead for the company?
Is Pandora having growing pains?
For the month of March, Pandora reported that listener hours rose 14% to 1.71 billion from the 1.49 billion management reported the same month a year ago. In addition to a greater hour count, the business saw its market share of the U.S. radio industry rise from 8.05% last year to 9.11% this year. Even in terms of active listeners the company's performance improved, rising 8% from 69.5 million last year to 75.3 million this year.
|March 2014||March 2013|
|Listener Hours||1.71 billion||1.49 billion|
|U.S. Radio Market Share||9.11%||8.05%|
|Active Listeners||75.3 million||69.5 million|
Using this data alone, investors might think the case for investing in Pandora is stronger than ever. With its market share on track to reach 10% within the next year, listener hours approaching 2 billion a month, and its active listener base comprising more than 20% of the U.S. population, there's plenty of positives to buying its shares.
However, investors got caught up on one negative tidbit of news. Compared to February of this year, Pandora's active listener base failed to budge. This gives the impression that, although the company has grown rapidly in the past, it might finally be hitting a wall due to market saturation and/or increased competition. Under either of these circumstances, growing its business would likely prove more challenging and costly moving forward.
Can Pandora survive?
Over the past few years, Pandora has been a terrific growth machine, but the company has been unable to turn a profit. Between 2009 and 2013, for instance, the company saw its revenue rise from a modest $55.2 million to $427.1 million, while its net loss widened from $16.8 million to $38.1 million. The main culprit behind the rise in losses has been the business's cost of revenue and selling, general and administrative expenses, both of which have jump as sales increased.
This problem seems to be unique to Pandora. SiriusXM Radio (NASDAQ:SIRI) has not had the same challenges extracting a profit from its growing revenue. Over the same timeframe, SiriusXM saw its revenue jump 52% from $2.5 billion to $3.8 billion as its subscriber base rose from 18.8 million to 25.6 million.
|2013 Revenue||2009 Revenue||Change|
|Pandora Media||$427.1 million||$55.2 million||674%|
|SiriusXM Radio||$3.8 billion||$2.5 billion||52%|
From a profitability perspective, SiriusXM's performance has been even better. Between 2009 and 2013, the company reported a significant improvement in its bottom line, with net income soaring from a loss of $352 million to a gain of $377.2 million. Unlike Pandora, SiriusXM benefited from drastically falling costs, mainly in the form of revenue growth that outpaced the rise in the company's cost of revenue and selling, general and administrative expenses.
Over this timeframe, the company's cost of revenue dropped from 43% of sales to 36.7%, while its selling, general and administrative expenses plummeted from 32.2% of sales to 14.6%. This is far better than Pandora's results, with its cost of revenue rising from 14.3% of sales to 68.1%; this was partially offset by its selling, general, and administrative expenses falling from 43.1% of sales to 36.5%.
|2013 Net Income||2009 Net Income||Change|
|Pandora Media||-$38.1 million||-$16.8 million||-$21.3 million|
|SiriusXM Radio||$377.2 million||-$352 million||$729.2 million|
Based on the evidence provided, it looks like Pandora might indeed be slowing down. Its other metrics stand at an all-time high, however, which suggests that the business has the same number of ears glued to its program for longer hours. This is certainly noteworthy, but the company has something a bit more serious wrong with it.
Currently, management is operating at a net loss and has been doing so for quite some time. This is sustainable so long as the business is growing rapidly, but if the company is beginning to show signs of fatigue then investors will focus more intently on its ability to turn a profit. With competition from other radio companies like SiriusXM that have been turning a profit, this could prove to be a major concern for shareholders going forward.
Daniel Jones has no position in any stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Pandora Media. The Motley Fool owns shares of Pandora Media and Sirius XM Radio. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
More from The Motley Fool
Why Riot Blockchain, Inc Stock Is Soaring on Monday
Shares of Riot Blockchain are surging with the price of bitcoin and the launch of bitcoin futures.
2017 Is a Year Discount Retailer Fred's Would Like to Forget
Things went from bad to worse after dreams of becoming a major pharmacy chain were dashed.
3 Great Gifts for Investors
Trying to find gifts for the investors in your life? Here are a few ideas to get you started.