Starbucks had a stellar year, opening 2015 at $82.13 and closing it -- after a 2-for-1 stock split in April -- at $60.03, according to S&P Capital IQ data. Effectively, that makes the yearly closing price the equivalent of $120.06, a change of 48.16%. Panera also had a strong 2015 opening at $175.03 and closing at $194.78, according to S&P Capital IQ, an 11.28% positive change in stock price. Krispy Kreme, however, went in the other direction, opening the year at $19.78 and closing it down 23% at $15.07, according to S&P Capital IQ.
There's a story that goes deeper than coffee sales as to why Starbucks was a home run, Panera hit either a long single or hustled out a double, and Krispy Kreme most certainly struck out.
Starbucks has it going on
It's relatively easy to see why Starbucks had a good year. The company saw global comparable-store sales rise 7% driven by a 3% increase in traffic, it reported in its Q4 earnings release. The company also reported that consolidated net revenues were up 17% over fiscal 2014 to a record $19.2 billion.
Starbucks also reported that it served over 60 million more customer occasions from its U.S. comp store base, and over 72 million more customer occasions from its global comp store base in fiscal 2015 over the prior year. The chain also added 1,677 net new stores, ending the year with 23,043 stores in 68 countries
"Starbucks' record Q4 financial results, highlighted by stunning comp store sales increases of 8% globally, 9% in the U.S. driven by a 4% increase in global traffic, demonstrate the strength and relevance of the Starbucks brand around the world," said CEO Howard Schultz.
It was a good year no matter how you look at it, and investors rewarded the company for its strong results.
Panera continues to evolve
While Panera also had a solid year, its results were not as uniformly positive as those of its coffee-selling rival. The company, which has only reported on its first three quarters, had a strong Q3. During the quarter, company-owned comparable net bakery-cafe sales increased 3.8%, franchise operated comparable net bakery-cafe sales increased 1.8%, and systemwide comparable net bakery-cafe sales increased 2.8% compared with the same period in fiscal 2014.
That's not as strong as Starbucks' growth numbers, but it's in line with the company's full-year prediction of growth between 2 and 3.5% at company-owned stores. Panera is in the early stages of rolling out a new design concept, dubbed 2.0.
As of the third quarter, the chain has completed the conversion of 291 bakery-cafes to Panera 2.0, with 108 conversions completed during Q3 and 185 conversions completed year-to-date. At the end of September, Panera consisted of 931 company-owned stores and 1,015 franchise operated bakery/cafes.
"Our strategic plan to generate increased shareholder value by making Panera a better competitive alternative with runways for expanded growth is working," said CEO Ron Shaich in the Q3 earnings release. "We are particularly pleased with these results in light of the slowing sales reported across the industry in October. Q3 represented our best performance in nine quarters."
Maybe Krispy Kreme deserved better?
On the surface, Krispy Kreme looks like it has had a pretty decent year. Through the first three quarters the company reported that revenues increased 6.4% to $388.4 million from $365 million. In addition, systemwide domestic same-store sales rose 4.7%, including a 3.1% gain at company-owned stores, though sales at international franchise stores declined 2.7%.
But the company didn't meet its sales projections, something that was driven not by its stores, but by its failure in grocery stores. That led to a higher-than normal level of returns from the chain's wholesale partner CFO George Price Cooper said during the company's conference call with analysts, CNN Money reported.
It was a classic case of overreaching and growing beyond demand that investors punished. The stock's big drop happened after Q3 results were reported, specifically punishing the shares because of the problems in supermarkets and other retailers.
To remedy that issue, Krispy Kreme plans to return to its roots in 2016 and 2017, focusing on growing the company's store counts.
"We are on track to open over 130 net new Krispy Kreme shops around the world in fiscal 2016," said CEO Tony Thompson in the earnings release. "More importantly, we continue managing Krispy Kreme for the long term by focusing on the tremendous opportunities we see for our iconic brand. Our energies are centered on driving sales, profitability, and reducing investment costs at small retail shops, which will strengthen our domestic expansion model for both company and franchise development."
Daniel Kline has no position in any stocks mentioned. He is drinking Starbucks coffee while he writes this, but enjoys the Krispy Kreme coffee pods. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.