Motley Fool Rule Breakers investors were thrilled to hear the news last week that recent portfolio inductee Stratasys
Not so with 3D Systems
Reviewing the results, CEO Abe Reichental pronounced himself "deeply disappointed with the revenue decline ... that affected our entire operating results for the quarter." In selling fewer machines, 3D was unable to maximize production efficiencies, and as a result its gross margin shed 1% to arrive at 42%. (By comparison, Stratasys is generating gross margins more than 10% higher.) On the plus side, 3D did manage to cut its operating costs. Unfortunately, the 7% decline here was only half the rate at which sales fell -- rolling the operating margin downhill as well.
Reichental attributed 3D's weak sales performance to "U.S. soft demand for end-user parts during the quarter," and noted that the lack of demand was compounded by the "relatively lower selling prices [on] ... mid-range prototyping systems and 3-D printers" that 3D did manage to sell. Meanwhile, sales of higher-margin large-frame systems were "anemic." That's a word Reichental also applied to the decline in sale of "materials" (the gunk that goes into 3D's printers to be transformed into physical objects).
All of which makes for quite a contrast with Stratasys' depiction of the quarter. Last week, Stratasys CEO Scott Crump agreed with Reichental that he was seeing "some small signs of weakness in our domestic markets." But unlike Reichental, Crump described global demand as "strong." Also unlike 3D, Stratasys enjoyed a "favorable product mix ... led by the standout performance of our proprietary high-end system business." Finally, as 3D's "materials" sales slipped 3%, Stratasys' rumbled ahead 14%.
A to-go box of Foolishness
Reviewing 3D's client list, and comparing it to Stratasys' rolling tally of customers landed, I'm struck by the fact that alongside names like Hewlett-Packard
Learn more about why we prefer Stratasys over its rival when you sign up for a free 30-day trial subscription of Motley Fool Rule Breakers.
More from The Motley Fool
Will 2018 Be Stratasys Ltd.'s Best Year Yet?
Stratasys Ltd. may be on the road to recovery, but that doesn't mean 2018 will be an outstanding year.
Carbon-Fiber 3D Printing Start-Up Snags Porsche, Siemens, and Microsoft as Investors
Markforged is best known for making carbon-fiber 3D printers -- a capability possessed by neither 3D Systems nor Stratasys -- but it also makes 3D printers that can print in other composites, as well as plastics and metals.
Stratasys Is Nearing Launch of a Super-Fast 3D Printing Tech for Plastics
The 3D printing company claims its tech is 50 times faster than the next fastest plastics 3D printing technology.