It's finally here: the time of year when folks like to take a look back at the year that was or make predictions about the year ahead.

If you're like me, looking back is like slicing open old wounds. So I'm going to spend the next few weeks discussing investing opportunities for 2009. I'll select some of the sectors that I follow, and then go out on a limb and predict next year's biggest winners.

I'll kick this off by taking a look at search engines.

The state of search
There were 7.8 billion searches performed in this country in October, according to Nielsen Online. That is a surprising 2% decline compared to last October's throughput. Combine that grim stat with the sorry state of marketing budgets in this sluggish economy and this doesn't seem to be the industry's finest hour.

Thankfully, not all search engines are the same. Let's dig deeper into the Nielsen data.

October 2008

Market Share

YOY Gain/(Loss)







MSN/Windows Live








Source: Nielsen Online MegaView Search.

Everyone knows that Google (NASDAQ:GOOG) is the market share leader, with a thick 61% slice of the pie. However, it is also gaining market share at the expense of Yahoo! (NASDAQ:YHOO) and Microsoft (NASDAQ:MSFT). Only Time Warner's (NYSE:TWX) AOL is taking healthier steps, but don't read too much into that. AOL has been yielding market share for years, so it was due for a dead cat bounce. Gaining 14.5% to hit a 4.3% slice is also smaller in absolute basis points than a larger company gaining 8.1% to reach 61.2% of the queries.

This leaves us with IAC's (NASDAQ:IACI) I think IAC is an attractively priced stock at this point, now that Barry Diller has split his media entertainment empire into five distinct companies. However, it would be hard to give top honors to a search engine player with waning traffic.

And the winner is: Google
How can one bet against Google at this point? It's widening the gap between itself and its two largest competitors. Analysts have been lowering their profit targets on the company -- and understandably so, given the softening ad market -- but the stock price has plummeted even more.

Google closed yesterday at just 14 times this year's projected profitability, and a mere 12 times next year's target. Admit it. You never thought that Google would get this cheap. When media markets bounce back, it will be the companies that gained market share during the lull -- like Google -- that truly spring back into life.

First runner-up:
You didn't think I would limit myself to just the stateside players, did you? (NASDAQ:BIDU) is the Google of China, with a similarly dominant market share. It's also hard to beat the price these days, with Baidu fetching just 18 times next year's earnings estimates. Since Baidu is growing quicker than Google, in a market growing quicker than Google's worldwide reach, Baidu is worthy of a premium.

Unfortunately, the reason that Baidu is trading with a forward P/E in the teens for the first time since going public three years ago is not pretty. The company got called out for accepting ads from unlicensed medical sponsors, a seemingly thin niche that makes up a troublesome 10% to 15% of total revenue at Baidu.

Baidu is doing its best to clean up its act, but this could be a double-whammy if it costs the company advertisers in the near term and integrity-seeking searchers in the long run. The warts are clearly there, but it's hard to ignore the huge upside potential here if Baidu gets it right.

For those troubled by Baidu's hiccups, a great alternative would be (NASDAQ:SOHU). Its Sogou search engine is tiny compared to Baidu, but the company provides new media diversification, and closed yesterday at less than 10 times next year's bottom-line guesstimates.

Second runner-up: Yahoo!
Yes, Yahoo!. At this price, it's hard to pass on the industry's distant silver medalist. Just consider the potential catalysts that may move shares of Yahoo! higher:

  • The CEO hunt to replace Jerry Yang may nab a magnetic outsider.
  • Microsoft has made it clear that it's not interested in renewing buyout talks, but it's hard to see how Microsoft can take on Google without Yahoo!.
  • Yahoo! has several Asian investments that may bounce back into favor even if Yahoo! itself remains stagnant.

No one needs to tell me that Yahoo! is broken and a laggard. I know it. However, as long as it remains a profitable and somewhat relevant player, the upside is so much greater than the downside.

So that's it! That's how I see search engine stocks stacking up in 2009. I'll be back with more sectors over the next few days.

Searching for more? Check out these headlines:

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium advisory service. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis -- even one of our own -- helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer.