Just what we need: another overreaching state attorney general trying to make a name for himself. Arkansas' attorney general wants to shut down payday lenders in his state, and he's sent letters to some 60 companies doing business there, telling them to pack up, ship out, and -- oh yeah! -- forgive all the debts of the people who borrowed money from them.
Unfortunately, payday lenders are used to feeling the strong arm of the law around their necks. North Carolina, Georgia, and about a dozen other states have outlawed payday lending. For individuals needing small bridge loans -- well, tough luck! You can't have one.
The move in Arkansas is a direct assault on the nation's largest payday lender,Advance America
From New York's Eliot Spitzer to Mississippi's Jim Hood and Mike Moore, we've seen attorneys general like Arkansas' Dustin McDaniel get creative with laws on the books to further their own agenda. Spitzer used New York's rarely used and little-known 1920s-era Martin Act to prosecute alleged white-collar crimes. Hood has been accused of colluding with trial lawyer Dickie Scruggs -- who just pled guilty to bribery charges in an unrelated case -- of trying to force State Farm Insurance to settle lawsuits over Hurricane Katrina by threatening to launch a criminal investigation. Before that, Moore sicced Scruggs on asbestos companies and the tobacco industry, reaping billions for the state as a result.
McDaniel's maneuver, however, seems unusual, because it's driving out of business -- and branding as illegal -- an industry that was specifically allowed to operate in the state of Arkansas by the state's Check Cashers Act. However, the state supreme court ruled that the act didn't give payday lenders "blanket protection."
Arkansas limits the amount of interest a lender may charge for a loan, as do many states. Exceed those limits, and you can be prosecuted for usury. The rent-to-own industry has run afoul of those laws from time to time. In 2006, New Jersey successfully prosecuted Rent-A-Center
That seems to be the rub here in Arkansas. While companies can't charge more than 17% in the state, the state's supreme court previously ruled that the fees charged by payday lenders weren't necessarily a violation. For the state's attorney general to now forbid companies from collecting on borrowers' debts, and demand that the industry leave Arkansas, seems a bit of a reach.
Advance America and Rent-A-Center are recommendations of Motley Fool Inside Value.
Fool contributor Rich Duprey owns shares of EZCORP, but he does not have a financial position in any of the other stocks mentioned in this article. You can see his holdings here. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.