Are tracking stocks a good investment?
Tracking stocks lets companies highlight a division that is performing well without letting weaker parts of the company have a negative effect on investment sentiment. For example, let's say a retail company's e-commerce business is growing rapidly, but its physical stores are struggling. In this scenario, a tracking stock related to its e-commerce business allows investors to put money directly into the high-growth segment without taking on the risks of the underperforming brick-and-mortar locations. This setup can attract more investment while keeping the company's core structure intact. In many cases, companies can use tracking stocks to raise capital without selling off part of their business. If the tracked division thrives, the company may even spin it off into an independent entity in the future.
While tracking stocks offers a targeted investment opportunity, there are indeed drawbacks. Investors in tracking stocks don't actually own a piece of the company's assets; instead, they just own a share in the financial performance of one division. This means they rely on the parent company to allocate profits fairly, but if the business faces financial trouble, it could shift revenue or costs between divisions, making the tracking stock less valuable. Tracking stocks can also behave in a more volatile manner than the entire company. Just as investing in a basket of stocks is generally less volatile than investing in one single stock, investing in a whole company tends to be less volatile than only one division.
How to invest in tracking stocks
1. Find tracking stocks and verify their status
Identifying tracking stocks requires thorough research, as they are not as common as regular shares. Start by checking a company's investor relations page or recent SEC filings, such as 10-K reports, where companies disclose details about their annual financial performance. Some firms may also announce tracking stocks in press releases or shareholder meetings, so reviewing these sources can provide valuable information.
Once a potential tracking stock is identified, analyze its financials to determine if it accurately reflects the performance of the tracked division. Look at segment-specific earnings reports and compare them to the tracking stock's market performance. Be very careful; if the parent company retains excessive control over revenue allocation, it could affect the stock's profitability.
2. Compare it to regular stock options and understand voter rights
Before investing, compare the tracking stock to the company's traditional stock. Sometimes, the parent company's overall stability makes a better investment than betting on just one of its segments. Tracking stocks can experience greater volatility, especially if investors speculate on a future spinoff or major shift within the business. Pay attention to whether the tracking stock has voting rights or dividend policies, as these factors influence investor benefits and risks. Tracking stockholders usually have limited or no voting rights, meaning they cannot influence company decisions like regular shareholders. This lack of control can be a disadvantage, especially if the parent company decides to restructure or sell the tracked division.