Why Etsy Inc Stock Jumped 25% Last Month

News of activist investors buying up shares boosted investor enthusiasm.

Jeremy Bowman
Jeremy Bowman
Jun 4, 2017 at 7:00AM
Consumer Goods

What happened

Shares of Etsy (NASDAQ:ETSY) surged last month after three activist investors disclosed their holdings in the crafty online marketplace. The stock climbed 25% in May, according to data from S&P Global Market Intelligence.

As the chart below shows, the stock jumped 22% on May 16 as two activist investors, TPG Capital and Dragoneer, said they would push to streamline the business after acquiring a joint 8% stake in the company.

ETSY Chart

Data by YCharts.

So what 

The call comes after Etsy stock continues to struggle after two years on the market -- the online marketplace made up of individual artisans has been unable to turn a GAAP profit despite running the fourth-most trafficked e-commerce site. 

The announcement from TPG and Dragoneer followed an earlier revelation during the month that Black-and-White Capital had also acquired an activist stake (about 2% of outstanding shares). In fact, that news came out on the same day as Etsy's disappointing earnings report, but management did seem to respond to earlier calls from Seth Wunder -- the founder of Black-and-White Capital -- to trim expenses.

When it reported earnings at the beginning of the month, the company also said it would lay off 80 staff members at its headquarters, or about 8% of corporate employees, and fire CEO Chad Dickerson. He was replaced by Josh Silverman, who has previously served as an executive at Skype and eBay.

Silverman responded to the activists by saying the company is pursuing "value-enhancing opportunities" and would "prudently invest in areas that deliver the greatest returns."

Several artists working on different projects

Image source: Etsy.

Related Articles

Now what

Investors tend to cheer activist intrusions, especially when demands for a sale are in the mix. Finding a buyer may not be so easy, however, as Jet.com is the only e-commerce company that has been sold for more than Etsy's market valuation of $1.6 billion.

With or without a prospective sale, the activist pressure should help move the company toward profitability, as there is significant evidence that corporate expenses are bloated, including a new Brooklyn office featuring a built-in irrigation system that captures rainwater from the roof, a printmaking studio, and a community weaving loom.

No news has emerged since the May 16 announcement, but look for progress reports to come out over the coming months. With three activist parties pushing for change, the company is likely to bend.