Surging demand for cybersecurity services over the next decade is a virtual certainty. But despite posting strong sales growth and having very strong long-term expansion prospects, Cloudflare (NET -3.34%) and CrowdStrike (CRWD -1.82%) have both seen dramatic stock pullbacks as macroeconomic pressures have mounted and investors have shifted away from companies with heavily forward-looking valuations.

Which of these top cybersecurity companies is most likely to deliver market-crushing returns for investors at current prices? Read on to see why two Motley Fool contributors have differing takes on which stock you'd be better off putting your money behind. 

A dollar sign in cyberspace.

Image source: Getty Images.

CrowdStrike's services are a necessity in today's world

Parkev Tatevosian: Cybersecurity firm CrowdStrike has shown impressive growth over the last several years. Indeed, revenue increased from $57 million in 2017 to $1.45 billion in 2022. As people spend more time and money online, the need to protect critical data is rising. CrowdStrike is capitalizing on that trend as a cloud-based device protection software leader. Spending on cybersecurity has turned from a nice-to-have to a must-have for enterprises and institutions worldwide.

More importantly, it is doing so while demonstrating economies of scale. Investors can find many tech companies that are growing sales rapidly. It is more challenging to find businesses that are expanding sales effectively. Between 2017 and 2022, CrowdStrike has improved gross profit from $19 million to $1.07 billion. That shows me that management is not looking at growth for growth's sake. If it continues at that rate, it could only be a matter of time before the profits trickle down to the bottom line.

Chart showing CrowdStrike's PE ratio falling sharply in 2022.

CRWD PE Ratio (Forward) data by YCharts

Fortunately for investors, the broad market sell-off in 2022 brought CrowdStrike's stock down to a reasonable valuation. It's selling at a forward price to earnings of 57.45. Investors have rarely had an opportunity to buy CrowdStrike's stock this cheaply. It might be an excellent idea to use this opportunity to scoop up shares of this growth stock at a discount.  

Cloudflare will keep pushing the internet forward

Keith NoonanCloudflare stands as the market's leading provider of software-based protections against distributed-denial-of-service (DDoS) threats -- a category of attacks that aims to take websites and applications down by flooding them with fake service requests. The company estimates that it blocks an average of 136 billion cyberattack instances each day.

The company also provides content delivery network (CDN) services that use edge computing to speed up the rate at which data is sent and received through the web. Across its products, Cloudflare has more than 162,000 paying customers, and it's in great position to continue attracting new clients and building relationships with those already using its services. 

Despite macroeconomic headwinds, Cloudflare managed to grow revenue 42% year over year in the fourth quarter, reaching $274.7 million. The company closed out the last fiscal year with $975.2 million in sales, up 49% on an annual basis, and it looks like the business's long-term growth story is still in very early innings.

Cloudflare is maintaining strong momentum because it's providing best-in-class service offerings and benefiting from a rising tide of cybersecurity threats and increasing demand for CDN services. As the overall internet continues to expand, Cloudflare is fantastically positioned to facilitate and benefit from that growth. 

Admittedly, Cloudflare continues to be valued at highly growth-dependent multiples even with the stock trading down approximately 72% from its peak level. With the company trading at roughly $20 billion and at roughly 15 times this year's expected sales, the stock could see volatile trading if macroeconomic pressures continue to shape the broader market backdrop in the near term.

But Cloudflare is a great company serving high-demand service categories, and I think that the stock actually offers a great risk-reward profile for long-term investors seeking cybersecurity plays capable of delivering multibagger returns. 

Which stock is the better buy?

If you're only interested in owning one of these stocks, the best move would be to make your decision based on business performance, fundamentals, and whether you think Cloudflare's web-services suite or CrowdStrike's endpoint-device protection services are better suited to driving long-term earnings growth. But investors don't necessarily have to take an either-or stance on this one. 

Both Cloudflare and CrowdStrike are leaders in their core respective service categories, and each business has a promising long-term growth outlook. Additionally, the companies are operating in different corners of the cybersecurity industry, and they've actually partnered on some important initiatives. For growth-oriented investors seeking to increase their portfolio exposure to the cybersecurity space, this is a case where buying both stocks could be the right move.