If I showed you a company with rapidly dwindling earnings, skyrocketing debt, a consistent culture of fiscal mismanagement, unfunded pension plans, unpayable accounts payable, and a tenuous credit rating, there'd be no way I could convince you to buy the stock, right?
What if that same company issued bonds with negligible yields, even as scores of less-impaired competitors saw their credit ratings cut? Would you line up to buy those bonds? Yet that is precisely what every holder of United States Treasury bonds has done.
The United States is a sovereign nation backing the reserve currency of the world, so I understand that the analogy is not exactly a clean one. After all, a sovereign state is not bound by the same rules that govern a corporation's practice. Unlike a corporation, a nation can theoretically issue unlimited mountains of debt; when buyers turn shy, it can even issue that debt to itself. But then again, isn't that precisely the problem here? Perhaps by assessing the fiscal status of the United States as we would examine a corporation, a clearer picture of the real face of this crisis could emerge.
Across every sector and in every corner of this great land, public corporations are taking prudent measures to hunker down and weather this storm. Deep in the heart of Texas, refiner Valero
While companies like these scale down dramatically to confront this recession in a fiscally responsible manner, how is it rational for the United States to issue unprecedented levels of new debt in an attempt to spend its way through? Congress is deliberating an $819 billion stimulus plan, which it will pile atop more than $8.6 trillion in potential outlays already tossed on the fire. We're told to expect another $2 trillion added to the ballooning national debt in 2009 alone. With tax revenue poised to decline, projected budget deficits of more than $1 trillion per year, and mounting unemployment, how exactly are we as a nation expected to repay all of this debt?
That, fellow Fools, is the critical question, and it draws a line in the sand that could ultimately constrain future spending. Thus far, foreign nations like China have financed our spending through the purchase of Treasury bonds, but at some point, total indebtedness from this scale of deficit spending suggests either of two unattractive scenarios: a strategic decision by a major foreign holder to begin unloading reserves in a meaningful way, or a downgrade of the nation's credit rating.
Those who have dismissed the latter scenario as impossible are no doubt reconsidering following Iceland's collapse; recent credit downgrades for Greece, Spain, and Portugal; and even the specter of a downgrade for Britain. In fact, Moody's quietly issued a warning about a potential downgrade of the U.S. credit rating more than a year ago, in the context of Social Security and health-care spending … back when a TARP was something for covering your firewood, and banks were presumed by many to be solvent. For a sobering example of what unsustainable levels of debt can do to a public corporation, look no further than bulk shipper DryShips
However urgent we're told each of the successive expenditures are, I believe that the fundamental unsustainability of this type of spending will result in the declining purchasing power of the U.S. dollar. Whatever your position regarding whether inflation or continued deflation will characterize the road ahead, neither scenario changes the underlying degradation of the dollar as the very perception of the nation's solvency comes into question.
The topic's not fun to consider, but I believe Fools must maintain an unfettered view of the dangers inherent in the present strategy of spending to confront the deleveraging process. Following a historic flight into Treasury bonds by investors worldwide as this crisis unfolded, many perceive a bubble in the making, which prompts the question: What safer haven exists than U.S.-issued debt? Trading at all-time highs against a host of major world currencies, and given recent gains against even the near-term relative strength in the U.S. dollar (compared to the British Pound, for example), I believe many investors are looking more seriously than ever to one time-tested safe haven asset: gold.