Wells Fargo
The numbers to prove it
JPMorgan Chase
Metric |
Wells Fargo |
US Bancorp |
---|---|---|
Q4 EPS: Consensus Estimate vs. Actual |
$0.61/ $0.61 |
$0.46/ $0.49 |
Total Loan Growth vs. Q3 |
2% (ann.) |
1.5% |
Reserve release* |
$875 million |
$25 million |
Tier 1 Common Equity Ratio |
8.4% |
7.8% |
Source: Company press releases.
*The reserve release is the amount by which net charge-offs exceeded loan loss provisions.
These trends are consistent with (and favor) a basket trade I highlighted at the end of November, which consisted of buying the top four U.S. commercial banks, on the assumption that the price tag for this dominant group of companies was very cheap. So far, the market appears to be coming around to that notion:
Company |
Return (Price only) |
Forward P/E |
---|---|---|
Bank of America |
33% |
11.9 |
Citigroup |
15.2% |
10.9 |
JPMorgan Chase |
17.3% |
9.4 |
Wells Fargo |
19.8% |
12.0 |
Basket* |
21.2% |
11.0 |
S&P 500 |
8.1% |
14.7 |
Source: Standard & Poor's, a division of Capital IQ, and State Street Global Advisors.
* Weighted by float-adjusted market-capitalization.
Of course, the outperformance could reverse in the short term, but I expect it to widen over the next 12 to 18 months.
Please sir, can I have some more dividends?
As far as dividend increases go, Wells Fargo and US Bancorp look like frontrunners to receive the go-ahead from regulators (along with JPMorgan Chase). Neither bank has the highest capital ratios in the industry, but they are well-capitalized, and they have no material exposure to investment banking. Thus, I think there are good odds that they'll conduct a first-quarter dividend hike.
Will an increase drive further price appreciation? If income-oriented investors/ funds return to these stocks, it's certainly possible. Regardless, the market is bound to revalue the bank basket shares, as the trends I mentioned above continue to reveal this group's formidable earnings power.