At The Motley Fool, we poke plenty of fun at Wall Street analysts and their endless cycle of upgrades, downgrades, and "initiating coverage at neutral." Today, we'll show you whether those bigwigs actually know what they're talking about. To help, we've enlisted Motley Fool CAPS to track the long-term performance of Wall Street's best and worst.
Who's hot, who's not -- in energy
Which companies will dominate the future of energy? Will it be old-line, developed-world oil-and-gas companies? Rising oil powers in the emerging market? How about the even trendier field of "alternative" energy, represented by solar power and rechargeable batteries?
Yesterday, Wall Street placed new bets on all three of these ideas. Here's what the bankers had to say about:
SandRidge Energy (NYSE:SD)
When it comes to one oil-and-gas play, black gold may turn out to be fool's gold -- at least in the opinion of BMO Capital Markets, which yesterday downgraded shares of SandRidge Energy. Although the company has been making moves to lighten its dependence on natural gas and focus more on oil exploration, BMO says the stock is still "significantly overvalued" for its prospects. Indeed, while investors yesterday bid the shares up by nearly 2% (to $5.84), BMO think they're headed the other way -- and assigns the stock a $2 price target.
I agree. Not necessarily with the $2 price target, mind you. I don't know what the stock is worth. What I do know, though, is that it's not worth 31 times earnings. Not with a 7% growth rate, no dividend, and a consistent record of burning cash when it should be generating cash for its shareholders, it isn't.
My hunch: This stock is worth a whole lot closer to $0, than to the nearly $6 a share investors are currently paying for it.
Petrobras (NYSE:PBR) (NYSE:PBR-A)
So, how about an oil stock a bit farther off the beaten path than North America? Brazilian oil giant Petroleo Brasileiro -- "Petrobras" to its friends -- scored an upgrade to "outperform" from the analysts at Credit Suisse Thursday, and a price target of $25 to boot. CS likes the company's move to raise the price on the diesel it sells and thinks this might be the catalyst that marks an "inflection point" in the stock.
Unfortunately, I'm compelled to differ here. Sure, on the surface, Petrobras shares look attractive -- I mean, P/E ratio of 12, 15% growth rate, and a 1.3% dividend? What's not to like? -- if you drill a little deeper, there's actually some pretty glaring problems with an investment in Petrobras.
Problems like the fact that much like SandRidge, Petrobras hasn't generated one red cent worth of real free cash flow in the past five years. And the fact that with no cash coming into its coffers, Petrobras has had to fuel its 15% growth rate by piling on debt. The company's currently $72.4 billion in hock (net of cash on hand), and the debt hole's getting deeper by the day.
In short, Credit Suisse's endorsement notwithstanding, I wouldn't touch this one with a 10-foot drill bit.
MEMC Electronic (NASDAQOTH:SUNEQ)
Next up, the wave of the future that wasn't: solar power. Prices on solar modules are down around the globe, and basically, no one is making money in this business... now. But according to the analysts at Goldman Sachs, this is just a temporary phenomenon. According to Goldman, MEMC's basic semiconductor business is "steady-growth, cash-flow positive," and worth $5 a share all on its own. If and when the solar biz ever turns around, therefore, buying a share of MEMC, which costs today only what the computer chip business alone is worth, gives you a "near-free call option" on a revival in solar.
I only wish I could agree. Unprofitable today and carrying $1.8 billion in debt-net-of-cash -- $500 million more than its own market cap -- MEMC Electronic is waltzing its way down the road to ruin. Even if one segment of its business is "cash-flow positive," the company as a whole is generating negative cash flow. Factor in capital spending and the company burned nearly $750 million last year.
Like its "old energy" rivals, MEMC is debt-heavy and cash flow light -- and headed lower.
Sociedad Quimica y Minera (NYSE:SQM)
Finally, we come to Chilean lithium miner SQM, whose products are instrumental in the making of lightweight rechargeable batteries, and whose name translates as "Chemical and Mining Company of Chile." SQM disappointed investors Tuesday with a report of $0.54 per share in profit. The good news is that it actually did earn a profit. The bad news is that, according to StreetInsider.com, it earned $0.08 less profit than Wall Street was hoping for.
This performance won SQM a prompt downgrade to "neutral" from analysts at Miller Tabak. Personally, though, I'm even less optimistic than the analyst.
On the one hand, SQM is probably the least overpriced of any stock mentioned in this column so far. Regardless, at 22 times earnings:
- The stock's overpriced for the 14% annual long-term growth that Wall Street estimates.
- It failed to grow earnings at all last quarter, shrinking instead.
- And -- as you can probably guess by now -- free cash flow isn't up to snuff here, either. In fact, the $313 million in cash profits SQM produced last year were less than half its reported $649 million in "net income."
Long story short, I wouldn't buy any of these companies today. Not a single one.
Fool contributor Rich Smith has no positions in the stocks mentioned above. You can find him on CAPS, publicly pontificating under the handle TMFDitty, where he's currently ranked No. 316 out of more than 180,000 members.
The Motley Fool recommends Petroleo Brasileiro S.A. (ADR) and Sociedad Quimica y Minera (ADR). Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.
More from The Motley Fool
Why SandRidge Energy, MBIA, and LivePerson Jumped Today
On a down day for the market, these stocks rose. Find out why.
Making Sense of SandRidge Energy Inc.’s Most Recent Acquisition
Diversification could save the company from this one hidden risk.
Oil Stocks: What Happened to the Looming Credit Crunch?
Banks seem to be kicking the can down the road by avoiding deep cuts into the credit lines of beleaguered oil companies.