At The Motley Fool, we poke plenty of fun at Wall Street analysts and their endless cycle of upgrades, downgrades, and "initiating coverage at neutral." Today, we'll show you whether those bigwigs actually know what they're talking about. To help, we've enlisted Motley Fool CAPS to track the long-term performance of Wall Street's best and worst.
Who's hot, who's not -- in semiconductor stocks
Today, though, we're going to introduce you to an analyst that fits neither of those categories. Wading into the semiconductor sector Monday is an analyst heretofore unknown to most investors -- one that, according to ratings tracker StreetInsider.com, has only just recently (as in December 2012) begun publishing its recommendations.
On Monday, this neither-best-nor-worst securities broker, Tigress Financial Partners, announced that it was initiating coverage of a series of three stocks in the semiconductor sector. Let's take them one at a time, and see how much sense Tigress is making, as it urges investors to ...
Sell Texas Instruments (NASDAQ:TXN) ...
Tigress starts investors off on a down note as it applies an "underperform" rating to shares of Texas Instruments, arguing that "key performance measures continue to decelerate, making TXN's current valuation unsustainable."
On the one hand, Tigress has a point about the deterioration in TI's business. Gross, operating, and net profit margins are down across the board at the Dallas-based chipmaker. On the other hand, though, I think TI still has a lot going for it as an investment. For example, capital spending at the company has been kept under tight control in recent years, even as the company has largely maintained (and even accelerated last year) strong free cash flow. Cash profits reached $2.9 billion last year, giving the stock a price-to-FCF ratio of about 13.
While that may not be a bargain price on a 9% grower like TI, the company's robust 3.2% dividend helps to bridge the valuation gap. At today's prices, I don't see TI as horribly overpriced -- more of a "hold" than an out-and-out "sell."
... hold NVIDIA (NASDAQ:NVDA) ...
Tigress grabs an even feistier feline by the tail with its analysis of graphics chip specialist NVIDIA. On one hand, the analyst calls NVIDIA's valuation of less than 14 times earnings, and less than 12 times free cash flow, "compelling." (So far, so good). On the other hand, though, Tigress trashes the stock's prospects by arguing that "performance drivers remain flat" and says it sees "little upside potential" in the stock.
I couldn't disagree more.
Missing from Tigress' analysis are several things that argue strongly in favor of giving NVIDIA a "buy" rating. For one thing, growth estimates of 10.6% and a strong dividend yield of 2.4% combine to give this stock a total return ratio of 13% -- which should easily justify the company's FCF valuation of 12. Plus, NVIDIA boasts a balance sheet plump with $3.7 billion in cash, and negligible debt. Factor cash into the equation, and NVIDIA has an enterprise value only 6.4 times annual free cash flow. On 10%-plus growth and paying a 2.4% divvy, NVIDIA's a real steal of a deal.
... and buy Qualcomm (NASDAQ:QCOM)?
Tigress reserves its strongest endorsement -- a "strong buy" rating -- for shares of Qualcomm, where the analyst sees accelerating "performance drivers" turbocharging "growing demand for 4G/LTE enabled smartphones and tablets" to produce "significant upside to the shares."
To an extent, Tigress is right about that. Net profit margins at the company are on the rise again, after slumping to below 28% in 2012. However, underlying the strong net margins growth is continued weakness in gross and operating margins, weak free cash flow ($5.1 billion versus $6.6 billion in claimed "net income"), and a 17 P/E ratio that looks only modestly attractive relative to long-term earnings growth expectations of less than 15%.
True, Qualcomm's 1.5% dividend helps to make up for the gap between growth and P/E. On the other hand, though, the company's weak free cash flow means that this stock actually costs closer to 22 times free cash flow (or 19 times FCF) when its cash-flush bank account is factored in). Either way, when valued on free cash, Qualcomm looks more expensive than its more modest P/E ratio makes it appear. While I suspect the stock's worth holding onto at these prices, I'd be leery of buying more until Qualcomm shows signs of getting its cash engine revving higher.
Bonus idea: Micron Technology (NASDAQ:MU)
That's it for Tigress' recommendations, but before we close out today's column, let's look at one last semi stock that was recently downgraded: Micron Technology.
Susquehanna cut Micron to "negative" yesterday, and I think the analyst is calling this one right. Unprofitable and selling for 15 times next year's earnings, Micron looks overpriced. If it's true that the stock is generating positive free cash flow again, its current tally of $510 million in trailing-12-month FCF still only gets the stock up to about 18 times FCF. Taking analyst estimates at face value, that's still too high a price to pay for 14% projected long-term profits growth.
With no dividend to recommend it (Micron is the only semi-stock on today's list that doesn't pay a dividend), it's hard to justify Micron's valuation at today's prices.
Long story short, out of all the stocks mentioned so far, I think NVIDIA is the best bet available, followed by Qualcomm; TI, maybe; and Micron, no way.
The mobile revolution is still in its infancy, but with so many different companies it can be daunting to know how to profit in the space. Fortunately, The Motley Fool has released a free report on mobile named "The Next Trillion-Dollar Revolution" that tells you how. The report describes why this seismic shift will dwarf any other technology revolution seen before it and also names the company at the forefront of the trend. You can access this report today by clicking here -- it's free.
The Motley Fool recommends NVIDIA and owns shares of Qualcomm. Try any of our Foolish newsletter services free for 30 days. We Fools don't all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.