Apple (AAPL 0.20%) stock has had a rough ride over the last year, after peaking above $700 last September. Two main concerns drove investors to sell the stock en masse. First, Apple's revenue growth quickly ground to a near-standstill. Second, it experienced severe margin compression, as production costs rose and customers traded down within Apple's product lineup.
After Apple shocked the world on Tuesday by announcing that its iPhone 5C would retail for $549 unlocked -- rather than the expected $300-$400 price point -- its investors no longer have to worry about continued margin compression.
The iPhone 5C. Source: Apple.
Revenue growth may remain anemic, but Apple is now very likely to return to year-over-year margin growth next quarter. This should produce a return to solid EPS growth.
Apple's margin problem
The following graph of Apple's gross margin over the past five years adequately explains investors' margin concerns.
AAPL Gross Profit Margin Quarterly, data by YCharts.
While Apple's gross margin rate has been unstable over time, it has generally oscillated around the 40% level since 2009. Gross margin spiked to 44.7% in Q1 of FY12 and peaked at 47.4% in the following quarter. However, over the following five quarters, gross margin plunged by more than 1000 basis points, hitting 36.9% last quarter. Apple's guidance suggests that gross margin will be similar in the current quarter.
Back in January, I argued that this margin compression was a temporary phenomenon, not the beginning of a long-term trend. The release of the iPhone 4S in October 2011 had driven gross margin to an unsustainably high level, primarily because the 4S maintained the form factor of the iPhone 4, lowering production costs.
With the move to a new form factor (taller but thinner and lighter) with the iPhone 5, production costs rose. This was one of the main factors that caused gross margin to return to lower (and more normal) levels in the past year.
Enter the iPhone 5C
Back in my January article, I argued that gross margin was likely to stabilize in a range of approximately 38%-41% by the end of this year. Had Apple introduced an iPhone priced at $299, or even $349, gross margin may have fallen out of that range. Instead, the 5C has an unsubsidized price of $549 in the U.S. It is even more expensive abroad, retailing for the equivalent of $733 in China.
The 5C is very similar to the iPhone 5, but it has a plastic exterior rather than the aluminum and glass casing Apple has been using recently. This will presumably cut down on manufacturing costs. This will be better for gross margin than the alternative of simply dropping the iPhone 5 price by $100.
Moreover, the iPhone 5S -- like the 4S -- maintains its predecessor's form factor. The main changes are upgraded processors and a new fingerprint sensor on the home button.
The iPhone 5S maintains the form factor of its predecessor, the iPhone 5. Source: Apple.
These commonalities could lead to a repeat of 2011, when the iPhone 4S drove a strong increase in Apple's gross margin for the fall quarter. Gross margin is unlikely to return to the all-time highs it reached two years ago, but I expect it to expand to the low 40% range.
Keep playing the long game
I was not very surprised to see Apple stock take a big hit following its iPhone announcement. Investors and analysts are overly focused on the revenue growth side of the value equation and were therefore hoping for a "cheap" iPhone.
However, margin expansion can be an equally potent driver of earnings growth. While I was surprised at just how high Apple was willing to price the iPhone 5C, the company is much better off erring on the high side rather than pricing aggressively for market share and thereby undermining profitability. If Apple's margins break back above 40% next quarter, this week's hand-wringing over market share will be virtually irrelevant.
