Source: ITC Holdings Corp. 

Entergy Corporation (NYSE:ETR) and ITC Holdings Corp. (NYSE:ITC) have officially nixed plans to transfer Entergy Corporation's transmission assets to ITC Holdings. More than two years in the works, this $1.8 billion dead deal is a blow to both companies. But with plans of their own, here's what it means for their futures.

Resistant regulators
The Mississippi Public Service Commission proved too much for Entergy Corporation and ITC Holdings Corp.'s patience. Since the beginning, the two corporations have worked with the regulatory body to gain approval for the spinoff, but the terms ultimately proved untenable. According to the Associated Press, the primary reason for the regulators' rejection is a potential $300 million rate hike for Mississippi customers over the next 30 years.

"While we strongly believe that the transaction would be in the best interest of our customers and all stakeholders, it is clear we don't have the necessary regulatory support to close the transaction," said Leo Denault, Entergy Corporation Chairman and CEO, in a statement Friday.

In a jab to local regulators, ITC Holdings Corp. Chairman, President, and CEO Joseph Welch noted: "We appreciate the support we received from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission and various stakeholders in the Entergy Corporation region who recognized and understood the benefits of the proposed transaction and the value it would create for customers."

Winners and losers
Entergy Corporation and ITC Holdings Corp. would never have fostered the deal if both companies didn't think it was in their best interest. Entergy Corporation would've benefited from extra capital to push elsewhere as it readies its power supply for what it deems "a historic level of economic development" in its service area that will add an estimated 2,000 MW of load to its current 30,000 MW generating capacity.

ITC Holdings Corp. would've benefited from more transmission scale. Claiming the title of the nation's largest independent electricity transmission company, Entergy Corporation's 15,400 miles of interconnected transmission lines would've essentially doubled (in length) ITC's transmission assets.

Source: ITC Holdings Corp. 

Scale is especially important for transmission companies, and is a major reason why companies like AEP (NASDAQ:AEP) and its 40,000-mile transmission network have managed to consistently grow share value and dividends over decades. AEP celebrated its 100th anniversary in 2006, and Entergy Corporation celebrates its own centennial this year. Power companies like AEP and Entergy Corporation are stalwarts of the stock market, and strategic scale investments and divestments play a large role in their continued existence.

Looking ahead
Although Entergy Corporation will have to hang on to its transmission and ITC Holdings Corp. won't scale up, neither company will suffer significantly. Entergy Corporation and ITC Holdings Corp. shares barely budged on the news, and longer-term trends continue to dictate each company's share price movement.

ETR Chart

ETR data by YCharts.

While investors have flocked to ITC Holdings Corp. and its consistent "toll booth" transmission revenue in turbulent times, Entergy Corporation investors have opted out as its large nuclear assets haven't held up to cheap natural gas. With more than 10,000 MW of nuclear power comprising around one-third of its total capacity, Entergy Corporation has been hit hard by natural gas in recent years. But gas prices are picking up, and nuclear-centric utilities like Entergy Corporation and Exelon Corporation (NASDAQ:EXC) are ready for a cost-competitive comeback.

Henry Hub Natural Gas Spot Price Chart

Henry Hub Natural Gas Spot Price data by YCharts.

Exelon Corporation and Entergy Corporation shares are both trading near 52-week lows, and their valuation gives investors significantly more upside than some of the more popular natural gas companies can currently offer.


Trailing P/E Ratio


Entergy Corporation



Exelon Corporation



Dominion Resources



Spectra Energy Corp.



Spectra Energy Partners



Source: Yahoo! Finance.

Entergy Corporation and ITC Holdings Corp. investors might be disappointed by this latest news, but it's no reason for long-term bulls to back off from either company.

This article represents the opinion of the writer, who may disagree with the “official” recommendation position of a Motley Fool premium advisory service. We’re motley! Questioning an investing thesis -- even one of our own -- helps us all think critically about investing and make decisions that help us become smarter, happier, and richer.