Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Trump's Phase 4 Stimulus Proposal Would Be an Epic Failure

By Sean Williams – May 15, 2020 at 6:06AM

You’re reading a free article with opinions that may differ from The Motley Fool’s Premium Investing Services. Become a Motley Fool member today to get instant access to our top analyst recommendations, in-depth research, investing resources, and more. Learn More

President Trump is convinced that reducing or eliminating the payroll tax and capital gains tax would be an effective means to bolster the economy -- he's wrong.

For the past two months, mitigation measures meant to halt the spread of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) have wreaked havoc on the U.S. economy and labor market. We've seen more than 33 million initial unemployment benefit claims filed, and the unemployment rate has rocketed from 50-year lows of sub-4% to Great Depression levels of 14.7%.

While these measures were deemed necessary to prevent additional loss of life tied to COVID-19, it's left many working Americans in dire financial shape. That's why, on March 27, Congress passed and President Trump signed the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act into law. The CARES Act, which tipped the scales at $2.2 trillion in size, provides money for hospitals, small business loans, distressed industries, expanded unemployment benefits and, of course, working Americans and seniors.

A messy stack of one hundred dollar bills, and a U.S. Treasury check lying atop a partially folded American flag.

Image source: Getty Images.

Stimulus money is very much needed, but it's not nearly enough for most Americans

The CARES Act ultimately set aside $300 billion for direct stimulus payments to what's estimated to be 175 million Americans. Single filers and married couples filing jointly can receive maximum payouts of $1,200 and $2,400, respectively, with qualifying children aged 16 and under adding an additional $500 per child to a parent's or household's payment.

At the same time, tens of millions of Americans won't receive a dime from the largest stimulus bill in history. This includes high-income earners (defined as single, married, and head-of-household filers with more than $99,000, $198,000, and $136,500 in respective adjusted gross income), non-citizens without a legal pathway to citizenship, and dependents aged 17 and older.

Through the first couple of weeks of the program, close to 90 million tax filers had received their Economic Impact Payment, as these stimulus payouts are officially known, with the average payout totaling about $1,792. That might sound like a pretty hearty helping of cash, but with so many Americans now out of work, it doesn't come close to covering most workers' or families' expenses.

According to an April-released Money/Morning Consult survey of 2,200 people, 74% expected their stimulus money to be gone in four weeks and nearly half are believed to have burned through their Economic Impact Payment in two weeks or less. With a majority of U.S. states still slowly reopening business activity, additional stimulus to support working Americans and their families may prove necessary.

President Trump speaking with reporters.

President Trump speaking with reporters. Image source: Official White House Photo by D. Myles Cullen.

President Trump has a specific vision for a phase four stimulus deal

The question, of course, is what this next round of stimulus might look like. In recent weeks, four proposals from both sides of the political aisle have been making their rounds on Capitol Hill. But if there's to be a phase four stimulus deal, President Trump has a very specific idea of what that package should include. 

In Trump's view, the best way to resolve the current economic malaise would be to eliminate or reduce the payroll tax, as well as the capital gains tax. In addition to stating that "we're not doing anything without a payroll tax cut," at a Fox News virtual town hall on Sunday, May 3, Trump fired off this tweet on May 5, outlining his phase four agenda: 

What's the thinking here, you ask? With regard to reducing or eliminating the payroll tax, it would allow working Americans to keep a greater portion of their income. Today, 15.3% of a worker's income goes toward payroll taxes -- 12.4% to Social Security on up to $137,700 in earned income, and 2.9% for Medicare, with no earnings cap. If you're self-employed, you're on the hook for this full 15.3%. Meanwhile, if you're employed by a company or someone else, your employer covers half of your liability (i.e., 6.2% of Social Security and 1.45% of Medicare).

If payroll taxes were permanently reduced or eliminated, the average working American employed by someone else or a corporation would get up to a 7.65% "raise." For the self-employed, we're talking about an up to 15.3% bump in take-home income.

Meanwhile, lowering or eliminating the capital gains tax would allow investors to hold onto more of their wealth, presumably encouraging additional investment into businesses and the stock market.

Red dice and casino chips laid atop Social Security cards.

Trump's proposed payroll tax cut would threaten Social Security's long-term solvency. Image source: Getty Images.

Trump's phase four proposal would be a monumental disaster

While Trump likely has the best intentions in mind to get the economy and stock market humming along again, as they were when the year began, attempting to reduce or eliminate the payroll tax and capital gains tax as a response to the coronavirus pandemic would be an epically horrible idea for a number of reasons.

First of all, a payroll tax reduction or elimination would only help Americans who still have a job. Presumably, the 33 million people who've filed for unemployment benefits over a seven-week period are the folks who need financial assistance far more expediently than those who still have a job and are receiving a paycheck each week. Yes, a payroll tax reduction or elimination would help a majority of Americans, but those who need financial assistance the most would not benefit from the change.

Secondly, but perhaps more importantly, the payroll tax is the primary funding mechanism for Social Security and Medicare. In 2019, Social Security generated 89% of the $1.06 trillion it collected via the payroll tax. Removing or eliminating the payroll tax puts Social Security and Medicare at serious risk of not being able to fully cover benefits.

Though Trump has suggested that corporations should be responsible for paying into these entitlement programs at a later date and ensuring their solvency, shifting the payroll tax responsibility entirely to the corporate realm risks tying the health of Social Security to that of the economy. That's a risk that should never be taken.

Third and finally, a reduction or elimination of the capital gains tax would, again, not help those who need it most. Only around 10% (or fewer) of people surveyed said that they plan to invest their stimulus checks, suggesting that few workers and families are in a safe enough financial position to consider investing at the moment. A capital gains tax reduction would only help a small percentage of Americans.

While no one knows what a phase four deal might entail at this point or if another stimulus package is even possible, one certainty is that Trump's desire to see payroll taxes and capital gains permanently reduced or eliminated has no shot at passing muster in Congress.

The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

Invest Smarter with The Motley Fool

Join Over 1 Million Premium Members Receiving…

  • New Stock Picks Each Month
  • Detailed Analysis of Companies
  • Model Portfolios
  • Live Streaming During Market Hours
  • And Much More
Get Started Now

Related Articles

Motley Fool Returns

Motley Fool Stock Advisor

Market-beating stocks from our award-winning analyst team.

Stock Advisor Returns
S&P 500 Returns

Calculated by average return of all stock recommendations since inception of the Stock Advisor service in February of 2002. Returns as of 10/03/2022.

Discounted offers are only available to new members. Stock Advisor list price is $199 per year.

Premium Investing Services

Invest better with The Motley Fool. Get stock recommendations, portfolio guidance, and more from The Motley Fool's premium services.