It's a chart of Bank of America's profitability since 2012, measured by return on average tangible common equity. This is the primary profitability target in the bank industry. It's calculated by dividing a bank's net income by its tangible common shareholders' equity.
An obvious takeaway from this chart is that Bank of America's performance is not only improving, but it's also getting more consistent. While the bank's earnings bounced around before 2014, they've since settled into a gradually upward-sloping trend.
This is important for a number of reasons. Stable earnings tend to support higher credit ratings, which bring down a bank's cost of funds. Less volatile earnings are also viewed favorably by regulators when they decide to approve or deny big bank capital plans as a part of the annual stress test. Finally, predictable earnings often translate into a higher stock valuation, as investors are known to abhor uncertainty.
Yet, while the trend toward consistency is important, it's not what caught my eye. What I noticed instead was the dotted line at 9%. That's Bank of America's internal estimate of its cost of capital.
Cost of capital refers to the opportunity cost associated with investing in a specific stock. It's somewhat of an esoteric concept, but the important thing to remember is that for a bank to create value for shareholders, its return on tangible common equity must exceed its cost of capital.
Banks that succeed at this, tend to trade for premiums to their book values, while banks that come up short generally sell for discounts to book value. You can see this relationship clearly in the chart here.
I've previously estimated Bank of America's cost of capital to be 11.7%. Another analyst has put it above 12%. Bank of America's own estimate is obviously more favorable.
This aside, Bank of America has made it clear that a 9% cost of capital isn't its target profitability. It's instead pegged a 12% return on tangible common equity as one of its three principal performance goals.
Bank of America still has ground to cover before it reaches that target, as its return on tangible common equity in the first quarter of this year was only 10.3%. But based on the bank's projections, it could be there by the end of this year.