He gave them fair warning.
Bart Chilton, a commissioner for the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC), earlier this month announced his intention "to speak out on the matter" of the commission's multiyear investigation into the silver market, adding: "I think the public deserves some answers in the very near future."
He has kept his word, delivering a crystal-clear assessment of what he has personally uncovered with respect to silver manipulation.
Chilton's full statement is posted on the CFTC's website (link), but the core of his message can be found in the following passage:
I believe that there have been repeated attempts to influence prices in the silver markets. There have been fraudulent efforts to persuade and deviously control that price. Based on what I have been told by members of the public, and reviewed in publicly available documents, I believe violations to the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) have taken place in silver markets and that any such violation of the law in this regard should be prosecuted.
On restoring integrity
He's not exactly beating around the bush, is he? To the contrary, Chilton's choice of words speaks directly to the long-standing allegations of foul play raised by seasoned silver market participants. Ted Butler, who has been a central figure in pressuring the CFTC to take action on this issue, stated that Chilton's statement "goes a long way toward restoring integrity in the CFTC."
Speaking of restoring integrity at the CFTC, Chilton is not the only agency figure taking his concerns to the public. George H. Painter, one of only two administrative law judges at the CFTC, alleged in his public retirement notice filed last month that his colleague, Judge Bruce Levine, has effectively made good on a promise he reportedly made more than 20 years ago to "never rule in a complainant's favor."
Finally, taking this integrity discussion back to silver, Chilton's professional assessment forces market observers the world over to grant fresh consideration to the whistle-blowing testimony of London precious-metals trader Andrew Maguire, who let the commission know of his allegations of silver price manipulation (including a warning of looming manipulation efforts on a specific later date). Not surprisingly, Maguire's assertions were widely met with incredulous opposition.
It appears, however, the CFTC may ultimately have taken those claims very seriously. The Wall Street Journal is reporting that CFTC lawyers have interviewed metal traders employed by JPMorgan Chase
The most likely outcome
Chilton refrained from delving into the specifics of the investigation, and also from forecasting a particular outcome of the CFTC's investigation. What he did offer, however, was his opinion regarding the best way to proceed. As he points out, the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act (aka FinReg) confers fresh authority upon the CFTC to address manipulation in commodity markets.
However, he conceded that even with those authorities, "the legal definition of manipulation under the law is a high bar to prove." As such, Chilton argued that attempted manipulation and other potential violations of law will be easier to prove than manipulation itself.
What does this all mean for silver?
I suspect that determined opponents to the notion of silver price manipulation will reference the lack of a massive upside breakout in silver prices following Chilton's statement as evidence that no price suppression exists. I would consider such an interpretation to be erroneous on multiple counts.
First of all, silver has already surged abruptly higher in recent weeks, marking more than a 25% upward move in just over two months. Ben Davies, chief executive of London-based hedge fund Hinde Capital, believes that recent pricing strength may have "curtailed the activity," and that an additional direct impact upon the price of silver is unlikely.
For disciplined long-term silver investors like myself, the desire to see increased transparency and enforcement against fraudulent market practices has never been about spawning a violent upward surge in the silver price. Violent movements in either direction are not in the best interest of investors. By lifting a veil of silence from the regulators' deliberations on the matter, I believe Commissioner Chilton has permitted the silver market to grow decidedly more resilient to any further attempts at price manipulation.
As such, I believe a heavy weight has indeed been removed from the shoulders of this silver market, and that subsequent accumulation of fundamental drivers for higher gold and silver prices will more readily exert their market-derived impact upon silver. I commend Commissioner Chilton for stepping forward courageously as a champion for the public interest.
I maintain my long-standing $50 price target for silver, and I continue to urge that Fools give careful consideration to acquiring some measure of silver exposure. The Global X Silver Miners ETF
Please take our Motley Poll then scroll down to the comments section to elaborate on your choice.
Gold is a hot topic on the blogs at Motley Fool CAPS. Join the free service today and see just how many Fools are taking the long view when it comes to investing in gold. The "Gold" tag at CAPS lists 62 potential investments, and you'll find Christopher's comments on most of them.
Fool contributor Christopher Barker can be found blogging actively and acting Foolishly within the CAPS community under the username TMFSinchiruna. He tweets. He owns shares in Silver Wheaton, Pan American Silver, Hecla Mining, Endeavour Silver, and Alexco Resource. True to its name, The Motley Fool is made up of a motley assortment of writers and analysts, each with a unique perspective; sometimes we agree, sometimes we disagree, but we all believe in the power of learning from each other through our Foolish community. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.