If you read my recent column on First Cash Financial Services
ACE Cash Express has more than 1,200 locations in 36 states, and in its most recent quarter increased year-over-year quarterly earnings per share by a staggering 32%, with an increase in comparable-store sales of 7.9%. By the end of fiscal 2005 (next June), the company expects earnings in the range of $1.94 to $2.00 per share, giving it an attractive forward P/E of just 14.
ACE also generates healthy, if not spectacular, free cash flow. It has twice as much cash as debt, and sports operating margins of 12.6% and net margins of 7.6%. Toss in an ROE above 15% and you see a business that is doing quite well for itself.
However, unlike First Cash, ACE Cash doesn't own any pawnshops. At first glance, that may not seem like a big deal. But when you realize First Cash's operating and net margins are 18.3% and 11.5%, respectively, the value of pawnshops should hit you right between the eyes. The reason for these higher margins is that pawnshops' annualized service charges can run as high as 240%, depending on the state. Also, when clients fail to repurchase their pawned items, First Cash's gross margins on the resale of forfeited collateral is a wallet-busting 45%.
ACE Cash has no reason to be ashamed of its business model. It's solidly profitable, and its margins are on par with competitors such as Cash America International
Fool Contributor Lawrence Meyers owns shares of First Cash and ACE Cash.