Lastly, there's a diversification benefit. So long as the BDC you invest in owns a diverse portfolio of investments, it's a nice way to spread your capital across multiple opportunities and risks at one time.
However, there are downsides, too. Those dividends can sometimes come at the cost of lower stock price appreciation. Most BDCs must distribute 90% of income, meaning they have far less retained earnings to reinvest and grow the value of the enterprise. And since most BDCs don't pay income tax, their distributions are not qualified. That means you will likely pay more in taxes on the distributions you get from the BDCs you own.
The result of paying out most of its earnings while still pursuing growth means most BDCs have a lot of debt as a percentage of assets. This means rising debt expense as they must refinance debt as it matures. This environment means potential risk and opportunity for BDCs now. Since interest rates have moved sharply higher, BDCs can potentially strike more lucrative new deals, but they could also be handcuffed by existing agreements that tie up their capital. And if portfolio companies struggle to repay their debts, a BDC could end up owning its assets and disposing of them at a loss.
Another potential issue with BDCs is fees. Just like with an open-ended fund like a mutual fund or ETF, the manager of the BDC will charge fees to cover its expenses, and these fees can be significant. According to Closed-End Fund Advisors, the 48 average publicly traded BDC had an expense ratio of 14.28% as of July 2023. In other words, access to these lucrative strategies comes with a significant cost.