Settle down, Fool. I know you're disappointed, but really -- the quarter wasn't half bad. Not nearly as bad as you might think from the 3% haircut investors are giving Navistar's stock price today.
Admittedly, today's bad news raised eyebrows. Fourth-quarter earnings dropped 55% in comparison to last year's fourth quarter. Full-year profits dropped 32%, as Navistar ended the year earning only $3.05 per share. And yes, revenue growth was anemic at just 5% for the year; it's also disheartening to see Navistar end on a low note, with Q4 sales rising at slower 2% pace. Yet, all is not lost.
Lost in the misery and malaise of analyst commentary today is the fact that Navistar actually did better than many folks thought it would. For example, pre-earnings, analysts were telling us to expect a 2.5% revenue decline. Instead, Navistar's revs grew, beating the consensus forecast by nearly 5%. As for earnings ... yes, they were down; there's no denying that -- but the reason they dropped is the real news: Navistar inked a new four-year contract with the UAW, which cost it $0.14 per share in Q4 profit -- but secures the company against similar labor-cost surprises for the next four years, and gives the company a contented workforce as it moves into 2011.
Also noteworthy: The very real possibility that Navistar is going to blow all these numbers away next year.
The opposite of ugly
I admit, I first discovered Navistar through its role as a competitor to Force Protection
CEO Daniel Ustian tells us that "the North American truck market has been depressed for three years." But going forward, Ustian expects to generate "solid returns to our bottom line in 2012 and 2013." Why? Because as I described last month, North American trucking is about to take its foot off the brake, as ancient trucking fleets turn over, and truckers like Heartland Express
Analysts expect this trucking renaissance to keep Navistar's profits growing at an annualized 9.3% pace over the next five years. With Navistar stock currently selling for less than five times free cash flow, I think that rate's plenty fast to justify owning the shares at today's prices.
Fools may not all hold the same opinions, but we all believe that considering a diverse range of insights makes us better investors.