Is CarMax profitable?
CarMax was profitable in its most recent fiscal year, which ended in February 2025. The company posted nearly $2.9 billion in gross profit, up 6.8% year over year, and diluted EPS of $3.21, compared with $2.75 the prior year. Fourth-quarter EPS jumped 81% to $0.58, though the stock fell 17% after results narrowly missed analyst expectations.
Investors were also unsettled by CarMax withdrawing its long-term targets for revenue, unit sales, and market share, citing uncertainty in the operating environment. Looking ahead, potential auto tariffs and a weaker economy add risk: higher vehicle and parts costs could pressure margins, while a downturn or tighter credit could hurt sales and increase loan defaults, especially since CarMax finances about 43% of its vehicles.